Wednesday’s Forum

OTB relies on its readers to support it. Please consider helping by becoming a monthly contributor through Patreon or making a one-time contribution via PayPal. Thanks for your consideration.

FILED UNDER: Open Forum
Steven L. Taylor
About Steven L. Taylor
Steven L. Taylor is a Professor Emeritus of Political Science and former College of Arts and Sciences Dean. His main areas of expertise include parties, elections, and the institutional design of democracies. His most recent book is the co-authored A Different Democracy: American Government in a 31-Country Perspective. He earned his Ph.D. from the University of Texas and his BA from the University of California, Irvine. He has been blogging since 2003 (originally at the now defunct Poliblog). Follow Steven on Twitter and/or BlueSky.

Comments

  1. Scott says:

    Recommended Podcast:

    From Bulwark’s Shield of the Republic.

    I really only knew about MBS from the brutal dismembering of Jamal Khashoggi. So this was enlightening but also this is a story of an authoritarian that is imposing changes on a country that can only be considered “progressive”. Many would cheer those changes but like Lenin, Stalin, Mao, Cesar Chavez, such people invariable turn to brutality when they are opposed. MBS, is in his early stages of reform and whether he follows that pattern remains to be seen.

    The Unlikely Rise of MBS (w/ Karen Elliott House)

    Eric and Eliot welcome Karen Elliott House, former long-time correspondent for the Wall Street Journal, President of Dow Jones International, Publisher of the Wall Street Journal and author of The Man Who Would Be King: Mohammed Bin Salman and the Transformation of Saudi Arabia (New York: HarperCollins, 2025). They discuss the rise of MBS, the scope of the changes he has wrought in the Kingdom in less than a decade in power, the ongoing forces of resistance to change, his effort to replace Islam with nationalism as a force binding Saudis together, and MBS’s views of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia as a “middle power’ in a world of great power competition.

    1
  2. Scott says:

    Who are the monsters?

    Venezuelan deportees say they endured months of abuse inside a Salvadoran prison

    Now that he’s free, Leonardo José Colmenares Solórzano, a 31-year-old Venezuelan, wants the world to know that he was tortured over four months in a Salvadoran prison. He said guards stomped on his hands, poured filthy water into his ears and threatened to beat him if he didn’t kneel alongside other inmates and lick their backs.

    Now that he’s free, Juan José Ramos Ramos, 39, insists he’s not who President Donald Trump says he is. He’s not a member of a gang or an international terrorist, just a man with tattoos whom immigration agents spotted riding in a car with a Venezuela sticker on the back.

    Now that he’s free, Andry Omar Blanco Bonilla, 40, said he wondered every day of his time in prison whether he’d ever hold his mother in his arms again. He’s relieved to be back home in Venezuela but struggles to make sense of why he and the other men were put through that ordeal in the first place.

    These are the accounts being shared by some of the more than 230 Venezuelan men the Trump administration deported on March 15 to a maximum-security prison in El Salvador known as CECOT. Throughout the men’s incarceration, the administration used blanket statements and exaggerations that obscured the truth about who they are and why they were targeted. The president has both hailed the men’s removal as a signature achievement of his first 100 days in office and touted it as a demonstration of the lengths his administration was willing to go to carry out his mass deportation campaign. He assured the public that he was fulfilling his promise to rid the country of immigrants who’d committed violent crimes, and that the men sent to El Salvador were “monsters,” “savages” and “the worst of the worst.”

    7
  3. Scott says:

    A little history:

    Ulysses S. Grant Picked a Confederate Slave Owner to Take Down the KKK

    President Ulysses S. Grant had put the night riders of the Ku Klux Klan on notice that he was ready to use the full powers of his office to break their white terrorist grip on the states of the former Confederacy. But he needed to pick an enforcer to break the Klan’s hold on the South.

    Grant already had the legal and legislative tools at his disposal for the job. In May 1870, Congress had approved the Civil Rights Act, also known as the First Enforcement Act, which was aimed right at the hooded thugs of the KKK. The law made it a felony with up to $5,000 in fines and up to 10 years in jail for two or more people to “band or conspire together, or go in disguise upon the public highway or upon the premises of another, with the intent to violate the civil rights of any citizen.”

    Grant needed an attorney general to turn the newly enacted 13th, 14th and 15th Amendments on citizenship, the right to vote and entitlement to due process of law for “freedmen” into courtroom weapons that would decimate the “Lost Cause” imaginings of the Klan.

    To do that, Grant made the unlikeliest choice of Amos T. Akerman, a minor postwar official in Georgia, to become the top law enforcement officer in the land.

    There is more history. To me, the story is that we ended Reconstruction too soon and we are still paying the price.

    9
  4. Scott says:

    The Pentagon Against the Think Tanks

    Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth has scanned the horizon for threats, and sure enough, he has found a new group of dangerous adversaries: think tanks, the organizations in the United States and allied nations that do policy research and advocate for various ideas. They must be stopped, according to a Defense Department announcement, because they promote “the evil of globalism, disdain for our great country, and hatred for the president of the United States.”

    This particular bit of McCarthyist harrumphing was the rationalization the Pentagon gave more than a week ago for pulling out of the Aspen Security Forum, a long-running annual conference routinely attended by business leaders, military officers, academics, policy analysts, foreign officials, and top government leaders from both parties, including many past secretaries of defense. For good measure, the Defense Department spokesperson Sean Parnell invoked the current holy words of the Hegseth Pentagon: The Aspen forum, he said, did not align with the department’s efforts to “increase the lethality of our war fighters, revitalize the warrior ethos and project peace through strength on the world stage.”

    We have a government by sound bite and by trolls. Like Hegseth, no substance at all.

    6
  5. Joe says:

    @Scott: And by “Cesar Chavez” I assume you meant Hugo Chavez.

    3
  6. Rob1 says:

    Israeli public figures call for ‘crippling sanctions’ on Israel over Gaza starvation

    Thirty-one high-profile Israelis accuse Tel Aviv of ‘brutal campaign’ and demand permanent ceasefire in letter

    The letter is significant both for its unvarnished criticism of Israel and for breaking the taboo of endorsing stringent international sanctions, in a country where politicians have promoted laws targeting those advocating such measures. [..]

    On Monday two well-known Israeli human rights groups, B’Tselem and Physicians for Human Rights Israel, released reports assessing for the first time that Israel was conducting a “genocidal” policy against Palestinians in Gaza, breaking another taboo.

    On Sunday the Reform movement, the largest Jewish denomination in the US, said the Israeli government was “culpable” in Gaza’s spreading famine. [..]

    More people in Gaza died of starvation in the last week than in the previous 21 months of conflict

    The latest interventions follow comments earlier this month by the former Israel prime minister Ehud Olmert, who told the Guardian that a “humanitarian city” Israel’s defence minister has proposed building on the ruins of Rafah would be a concentration camp, and forcing Palestinians inside would amount to ethnic cleansing.

    https://www.theguardian.com/world/2025/jul/29/letter-sanctions-israel-gaza-starvation

    5
  7. Scott says:

    @Joe: Yes, indeed. My bad. Thanks for catching that.

    1
  8. Rob1 says:

    @Scott:

    Defense Department announcement, because they [think tanks] promote “the evil of globalism

    I always have to laugh-cringe when the MAGA crowd rails against the bogeyman of “globalism” —- a cause for the deeply uninformed and terminally naive.

    MAGA leadership isn’t against all globalism, just that which they can’t control or profit from. And in a broad sense, railing against globalism is like shaking their fists at the weather — it’s force majeure, built into elemental human nature. But try explaining that to Fox News audiences whose very lifestyle as ultimate consumers, is utterly dependent on the largess of “globalism.”

    7
  9. Kathy says:

    Yesterday a supervisor who’s on vacation called to yell at me for having listed the wrong brand of frozen juice concentrate. She demanded I find the emails from the operations area where they defined which brand was to be used.

    Surprise! The emails contained files indicating the brand I’d listed.

    I don’t get why it’s a big deal, much less why over halfway through a year-long contract it’s even an issue at all. When this happens we usually come to some agreement with the customer, and the contract is amended to reflect the change. And this gets sorted out in the first few weeks of the year’s contract.

    In any case, we offered the brand operations listed. If there’s a problem, it’s their problem.

    1
  10. Kathy says:

    Some years ago I said the chief nazi’s most consequential venture was making EVs cool and mainstream. Well, he’s ruined that, too.

    On the upside, even with the As*holemobile (aka Xybertruck), conservatives are still no more likely to purchase en EV, not even a swastikar.

    3
  11. Rob1 says:

    The Men Trump Deported to a Salvadoran Prison

    We obtained internal data showing the Trump administration knew that at least 197 of the men had not been convicted of crimes in the U.S. — and that only six had been convicted of violent offenses. We identified fewer than a dozen additional convictions, both for crimes committed in the U.S. and abroad, that were not reflected in the government data. [..]

    At least 166 of the men have tattoos. Interviews with families, immigration documents and court records show the government relied heavily on tattoos to tie the men to the Venezuelan gang Tren de Aragua — even though law enforcement experts told us that tattoos are not an indicator of gang membership

    https://projects.propublica.org/venezuelan-immigrants-trump-deported-cecot/

    Trump Administration’s response by White House spokesperson Abigail Jackson:

    [ProPublica is a] liberal rag hellbent on defending violent criminal illegal aliens who never belonged in the United States. America is safer with them out of our country.”

    https://www.texastribune.org/2025/07/30/venezuelan-men-cecot-trump-salvadoran-prison-abuse/#:~:text=Last%20week%2C%20we%20published%20a,not%20enough%20about%20their%20victims.%E2%80%9D

    Thank goodness we have a country governed by people at the highest levels dedicated to human rights, and transparency around its own actions without demonizing its critics, unlike some of those authoritarian, fascist regimes in the last century. How could one ever make such a comparison? On what basis? Where’s the data?

    6
  12. Dutchgirl says:

    My home and general safety were never at risk yesterday, but the seriousness of the waves generated by the earthquake had me check and prepare my emergency plan. Happily the waves were not catastrophic. Kiddo and I just stayed home, glued to the news as the sirens wailed every hour. Beaches remain closed.

    4
  13. Eusebio says:

    @Kathy:
    Because Teslas comprised nearly half of the EVs sold in the US last year, and their brand name features prominently on banks of public charging stations, a lot of people will need time to reassess what their EV would be and how they would charge it.

  14. Joe says:

    @Scott:

    because they [think tanks] promote “the evil

    Frankly, I think tanks promote evil too.

  15. Rob1 says:

    @Joe: But not uniformly, right?

  16. Kathy says:

    @Eusebio:

    I haven’t exactly been following the charger matter, but I think there are adapters for most non-Texla models so they can use the Swastikar chargers.

  17. Eusebio says:

    @Kathy:
    True, but EV-charging station compatibility has been evolving, and there’s not yet one answer. I’m not saying it’s a show-stopper of an issue, but those who haven’t already bought an EV, or researched buying and charging one, may need some time to learn more and get used to the idea of possibly using charging stations having a tainted brand.

  18. Kathy says:

    @Eusebio:

    I hadn’t considered that last.

    Absent a massive crash, though, it’s doubtful the chief nazi would sell his stock* and leave the company, or even that he could be eased out a la Steve Jobs from Apple.

    *Ironically selling all his stock would create the crash. Catch-22…

  19. Kathy says:

    Currently reading Allergic by Theresa MacPhail. Spoiler alert, it’s about allergies. I consider it an extension on my reading about the immune system. Allergies have more to do with the innate part of the system than the adaptive part.

    It’s also far more complex than most books on immunity describe. after all, it plays a limited role in response to infection, past activating the adaptive part and producing many of the early symptoms.

  20. Kathy says:

    If I took these kinds of compulsory courses, I’d wind up thinking there’s something to antisemitism, and I’m Jewish.

    Seriously. For the past two years Israel has been conducting a cruel and massively destructive war, that no amount of 7th Octobers can justify. Add the latest strategy of starving the whole population, and explicit mention of expelling all Palestinians form Gaza, and who wants to rationally equate criticism of Israel wit antisemitism?

    Time for the Israelis to kick the fascists out of their government.

    2
  21. Kathy says:

    Related to the previous comment, another prominent fascist opened a diner-themed restaurant in LA.

    I wasn’t going to comment on it because 1) who cares? and 2) all the bad reviews and stress on glitches, holdups, fu*kups, long lines, enthusiastic supporters, gimmicks, people giving up on lunch once they realize it’s dinner time already, running out of food, equipment malfunctions, etc., are rather typical for new restaurant openings*.

    But there are protests, and that is worth mentioning.

    Note this clueless chief nazi supporter:

    “If he’s a fascist, who has he killed?” the man asked. “Nazis kill people, from what I understand.”

    Besides the obvious, I’d ask him: what about all the people he cut off USAID without even a minute’s grace to let someone else take up food and medicine distribution to dirt poor and dispossessed people? How many did he kill that way?

    *This is one reason many restaurants, and other venues, do an unadvertised soft opening before the formal, overhyped, grand opening.

    3
  22. Gavin says:

    One thing I find revealing about the second Trump term is the degree of mask-off these R whackjobs have decided is Finally Acceptable Really This Time. Political correctness really, to Republicans, has all this time actually meant that because they can no longer use the N word and beat their wives — and receive no consequences — then Society Is Ending Imminently or whatever.
    Yarvin’s recent multiple tweets going on about “billionaires are N Rich” is both insane and entirely unhelpful from a policy perspective [ “The nature and function of their wealth is profoundly negrous” is an actual sentence he typed and posted ] …. and to me it does mean that we really need to bring back shame and societal ostracizing.
    Obviously, fascists aren’t cool or useful or otherwise a productive part of society —– because if your “beliefs” unalive people who disagree with you, you don’t get to use that lodestone of liberal democracy “free speech.” Eliminating the discussion of this is [one of] the limits to free speech that needs to be both restored and defended.. as one example, Austria still does it.

    2
  23. Richard Gardner says:

    I had a good laugh at this from 2013. There has been lots of scam in the Green agenda (Green $$$ in Green). But much of solar and wind power does make sense, just not all. I’m familiar with EU politics – this skit is not about America (sorry, world does not revolve around the USA). Enjoy
    https://x.com/therealmrbench/status/1950579819831259161