Wednesday’s Forum

FILED UNDER: Open Forum
Steven L. Taylor
About Steven L. Taylor
Steven L. Taylor is a Professor Emeritus of Political Science and former College of Arts and Sciences Dean. His main areas of expertise include parties, elections, and the institutional design of democracies. His most recent book is the co-authored A Different Democracy: American Government in a 31-Country Perspective. He earned his Ph.D. from the University of Texas and his BA from the University of California, Irvine. He has been blogging since 2003 (originally at the now defunct Poliblog). Follow Steven on Twitter and/or BlueSky.

Comments

  1. Bobert says:

    BTW, It occurs to me that the approach that ICE has adopted to apprehend the “worst of the worst” is comparable to the Jeff Sessions “Family separation” tactic.
    Broad support for the goal, but condemnation for the methods used.
    Among other things, ICE somehow thinks they they do not need to be accountable. Specifically I would like to see the actual numbers of judicial warrants compared to the number of people that are being accosted (pulled from cars, confronted in stores, schools, courthouses, homes being broken into).
    Personally, I am also distressed by the notion that an alien, having been convicted of some offense, served their time, and has successfully rehabilitated, is not acceptable in our society,

    4
  2. Scott says:

    Every day, it is something. I’m used to writing my Congresscritters but rather than detailed, reasoned letters, I’m down to 2-3 sentence screeds along the lines of “Senator Cornyn, you ignorant slut…”. It does save time and I just cut and paste in the letter to Cruz.

    Not that they care, though.

    7
  3. Scott says:

    Texas defends law requiring schools to post Ten Commandments. Here’s what to know.

    The 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals heard arguments Tuesday over a Texas law requiring public schools to display posters of the Ten Commandments in classrooms.

    All 17 active judges on the court listened to the case — Rabbi Nathan v. Alamo Heights Independent School District — alongside a similar challenge in Louisiana, the first state to pass a Ten Commandments requirement.

    Why the families sued: The lawsuit argues that the law subjects the families’ children to a state-imposed Protestant version of the Ten Commandments that many religious and nonreligious Texans do not recognWhy the families sued: The lawsuit argues that the lawize.

    The families believe the law seeks to pressure students into observing and adopting Texas officials’ preferred religious principles.

    They also say the law will inflict harm by alienating children of those who do not follow the state’s preferred religion, as well as by undercutting parents’ authority to direct their children’s religious education.

    “Posting the Ten Commandments in public schools is un-American and un-Baptist,” Griff Martin, a pastor, parent and plaintiff in the lawsuit, said in a statement. “S.B. 10 undermines the separation of church and state as a bedrock principle of my family’s Baptist heritage. Baptists have long held that the government has no role in religion — so that our faith may remain free and authentic.”

    5
  4. Scott says:

    Ex-military leaders back Mark Kelly in lawsuit against Hegseth

    More than 40 former military leaders are backing Sen. Mark Kelly’s (D-Ariz.) lawsuit against the Pentagon, saying they are “deeply concerned” Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth’s threats against the retired naval officer could chill the speech of other former service members.

    “Disciplining Senator Kelly for engaging in protected, political speech violates the First Amendment and, if permitted to stand, would chill public participation by veterans around the country,” the group states in the 21-page brief filed in U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia.

    “Diverse viewpoints are critical to a healthy and free marketplace of ideas, and silencing veteran voices would be especially harmful — depriving the public of experienced and informed views on critical matters of national security.”

    “Nothing in the statute authorizes the Department of Defense to reopen that determination based on post-retirement political speech – and if it did, it would raise serious constitutional concerns and subject all of the nation’s retired veterans to an ever-present threat against their retirement,” according to the case.

    10
  5. Scott says:

    A little history.

    When the Air Force had a guy jump from the edge of space

    By the late 1950s, the Space Race was dominating the Cold War, the United States military was rapidly testing advanced fighter jets and looking at how it could build out its rocket arsenal both for offensive use and to send Americans into space. And then they hit a snag.

    The U.S. military had so rapidly built out its new aircraft that it had a new problem. Jets, like the X-15, could hit the upper atmosphere and break the sound barrier. However high altitude and high speeds meant that bailing out of these aircraft was riskier than ever. Beyond their rapid speed, pilots would have to deal with limited oxygen, extreme cold and the risk of spinning out at terminal velocity.

    It led to Project Excelsior, where the United States Air Force would intentionally send an airman into the stratosphere to then jump back to Earth, in the hopes of perfecting parachute technology. The project kicked off in 1958.

    Air Force scientists designed a multi-stage parachute, and soon the service needed to test it. Crews designed a gondola that would, using a helium balloon, carry a person miles up into the stratosphere to then jump and deploy the parachute system. Enter Air Force Capt. Joseph Kittinger, who took part in one of the wildest scientific experiments of all time.

    The third and final test happened on Aug. 16, 1960. For this final jump, Kittinger went nearly 20 miles up. There were already problems. The pressure suit had a minor flaw; one glove hadn’t pressurized, leaving one hand swelling from low atmosphere and leaving Kittinger unable to pull at his ripcord. Kittinger took the balloon up to a record 102,800 feet above Earth and despite the challenges, he jumped off of the gondola. Kittinger reached a top speed of 625.5 miles per hour, falling for more than four minutes. The parachute deployed and worked as intended, safely slowing him and helping him return to Earth.

    You would think that would be enough excitement and achievement for a career. But no..

    Kittinger would later serve in several combat tours in Vietnam, eventually being shot down in 1972 and spending 11 months as a prisoner of war before being released. He would earn four more Distinguished Flying Crosses during the war.

    4
  6. Neil Hudelson says:

    Responding to Kathy’s comment yesterday about needing to make a sauce creamy but not too creamy:

    A long time ago I followed a NYTimes recipe for Fennel Gratin, and it had a genius little move of blending cannellini beans (maybe some of their water, cant’ remember) with a few tablespoons of heavy cream. The pureed beans provided a similar body as the cream without being too heavy. The cream added….well, the creaminess.

    2
  7. steve222 says:

    @Bobert: “ICE somehow thinks they they do not need to be accountable”

    Existing evidence suggests that they actually are nearly unaccountable. When their most egregious acts are caught on camera the people they have wrongly assaulted and/or arrested get released with no charges but to date it’s very rare that the ICE officers face any consequences.

    Steve

    7
  8. Michael Reynolds says:

    In round numbers there are 8 billion humans on planet earth. There are 335 million Americans. 40% of that 335 million, or about 135 million people think Donald Trump is not a moron.

    98.4% of humans think Donald Trump is a moron. That is greater than the number of people who believe the earth is a sphere, or that the sky is blue, or that water is wet.

    3
  9. Kathy says:

    @Neil Hudelson:

    One trick I use is to put cottage cheese and milk in the blender and liquefy the whole thing. In this case it would make the sauce more creamy than I want. It’s more about texture this time than flavor.

  10. Kathy says:

    Halligan has left the misnamed justice dept.

    Maybe she can get some other job she’s unqualified to do. How about El Taco’s personal physician?

    3
  11. CSK says:

    @Kathy:

    She’s very good-looking. According to Trump, doesn’t that qualify her to do everything?

    4
  12. Jc says:

    Anyone read transcript of Trumps rant? Dude spoke of Greenland then later starts talking about Iceland, meaning Greenland, it is beyond bizarre. If that is not a sign of early dementia I am not sure what else to say. I understand that detecting early signs of dementia in narcissists is difficult, but it appears that is what it has to be. Maybe someone could plug in both Davos 2025 vs. Davos 2026 into AI and see if it can identify signs of dementia related cognitive decline. It is definitely there, man. Embarrassing non factual ranting, so bizarre.

    4
  13. charontwo says:

    @Jc:

    Link

    Link

    Link

    2
  14. charontwo says:

    @Jc:

    “We probably won’t get anything unless I decide to use excessive strength and force where we would be, frankly, unstoppable,” Mr. Trump said. “But I won’t do that. That’s probably the biggest statement, because people thought I would use force. I don’t have to use force. I don’t want to use force. I won’t use force. All the United States is asking for is a place called Greenland.”

    He is, for some reason, backing off threatening force. Perhaps some sort of counter threats, or maybe just how stock/bond markets are acting.

    2
  15. Scott says:

    Law that I would like the see:

    All official government communications (legislative, executive, and judicial) must be published on government funded media. Use of other media (such as X, Truth Social, 3rd party sites, etc.) may not be used.

    Brain fart of the day.

    4
  16. Slugger says:

    @charontwo: I won’t use force! BTW, anyone want to buy some Venezuelan oil at a good price?

    4
  17. CSK says:

    @Slugger:

    FFS, Trump is nucking futs. I know it, you know it, the whole world knows it.

    2
  18. Beth says:

    Holy shit folks, who wants to laugh at Tim Scott and the rest of these dumb motherfuckers?

    The NRSC is also out with a new memo about the race, calling Minnesota — which went for Vice President Kamala Harris by 4 points in 2024 — “firmly in play for Republicans.”

    Man, I want some of the drugs they got.

    2
  19. Beth says:

    Assuming this population density map is accurate, how many people do you think are gonna vote for Republicans after this?

    1
  20. Mr. Prosser says:

    Well, the lower basin states that rely on the Colorado River (Arizona, Nevada, California) are going to have an interesting year. We’re in a snow drought here in the Rockies and Western Slope. Colorado’s snowpack is the lowest on record for this time of year, and major river basins are running at about 50 percent to 75 percent of normal. The Colorado River headwaters are at 58%. December 2025 was also the warmest ever on record, with over 1,000 daily high temperature records set across the state, according to the Colorado Climate Center. Their latest report called it “Exceptional. Record-smashing. Disturbingly warm.”https://www.cpr.org/2026/01/20/winter-drought-threatens-spring-water-supply/?utm_source=npr.org&utm_medium=referral&utm_campaign=local_headlines&utm_content=homepage

    2
  21. Jax says:

    @Mr. Prosser: It’s going to be an interesting year in the Upper Basin states, as well. Our mountain snowpack is at or slightly below normal, but there is no snow in the valleys at all. It rained on Christmas Day in what’s called “The Icebox of the Nation”. I went to Oregon to take my first load of stuff out this last weekend, and it was warmer in Wyoming than it was in Oregon!

    3
  22. becca says:

    People around here lose their minds when a winter storm is predicted. I got stuck at Kroger for three hours yesterday. I hope the storm is more snow than ice, but the weather models keep updating to more chances of an ice storm and less snow. I can’t ugh enough.

    I will make chili and some creamy chicken and wild rice soup. Easy to heat up in the microwave if we lose power and go on generator. We have two 100 gallon propane tanks. One is close to empty, but the other is full. Very fuel efficient and no worries about gasoline rationing. We should be good.

  23. Sleeping Dog says:

    @Jax:

    “The Icebox of the Nation”

    Embarrass, MN will fight you for that title.

    @becca:

    This happens everywhere. I do like the fact that the shopping carts are full of perishables… And I wonder what happened to the shovel that they bought for the last storm.

    1
  24. Kathy says:

    @Jax:

    Those Chinese hoaxers are really thorough, aren’t they?

    4
  25. Kathy says:

    @charontwo:

    Those links ought to be good for a few million nightmares.

    What I wonder is why so many in his cabinet and advisors play along, and especially why so many in his base also play along. it reminds me of a rare psychiatric diagnosis, Folie à deux, writ very large.

    IMO psychiatrist should study this. If there’s something to it, they can call it trump derangement syndrome.

    2
  26. Gustopher says:

    https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2026/jan/21/ice-arrest-pepper-spray-protesters-minnesota

    An appeals court has temporarily lifted restrictions from a federal judge in Minnesota that blocked ICE agents from pepper-spraying and arresting peaceful protesters.

    In a victory for the Trump administration, the eighth US circuit court of appeals on Wednesday granted the justice department’s request for an administrative stay of a preliminary injunction issued last Friday by Judge Katherine Menendez.

    Menendez’s preliminary injunction would have prohibited ICE agents from retaliating against peaceful protesters, arresting or detaining people who are participating in peaceful protests, using pepper spray or similar non-lethal munitions and crowd dispersal tools, as well as stopping or detaining drivers without reasonable cause.

    Awesome. Perhaps The Guardian is misrepresenting things, although they tend to be pretty reasonable.

    Meanwhile, the weather for Minnesota includes … exploding trees?

    https://973kkrc.com/exploding-trees-minnesota-iowa-south-dakota/

    If the Second American Revolution is sparked by people on edge reacting to an exploding tree, we will clearly be living in the stupidest of all possible timelines.

    2
  27. Mr. Prosser says:

    @Jax: Same down here and even the rain wasn’t much, less than 0.10″. I’m sure BuRec will draw down Blue Mesa Reservoir to a trickle to keep Glen Canyon generating and I won’t be surprised if Flaming Gorge up in your neck of the woods gets the same treatment.

    1
  28. JohnSF says:

    @charontwo:
    @Jc:
    I listened to a good chunk of that statement by Trump.
    Ye gods.
    He really has totally lost it.
    Just rambling inanity.

    4
  29. Sleeping Dog says:

    @JohnSF:

    Ambient -20F and below brings lots of interesting sounds, you’re sitting there by the fire with a good book and a favorite bourbon/scotch/cognac and then there is a bang similar to a gunshot and you start poking around looking for the source and can’t find anything. It’s just the houses structure reacting to the cold.

    1
  30. Jax says:

    @Sleeping Dog: You know, I’ve always wondered about that! Apparently there were two towns in the upper midwest claiming the title years back, and one finally won the “official” title, but nobody ever mentioned our tiny little town of 325 in BFE, Wyoming. 😉

    1
  31. wr says:

    @Beth: First question on the campaign trail: “So, Michelle, do you think that ICE should be allowed to kill civilians if they don’t show proper respect?”

    1
  32. JohnSF says:

    @Sleeping Dog:
    The coldest I’ve ever known it here was -15; but that of course is C, not F.
    Minus 28C is scary cold.

    But I recall someone I knew who lived for a time in Calgary, who maintained it was bearable, because compared to British winters, which are raw and soggy, it’s a dry cold, with the atmosphic moisture having simply frozen out.
    So she said, as long as you wrapped up, and had a warm house, the humidity chilling effect was much less.

    Personally, I’ll rather credit it than experience it in person.

    Stay warm!

    1
  33. charontwo says:
  34. CSK says:

    Kyle Rittenhouse says he would have shot Renee Good.
    He’s as pathetic as he is dangerous.

    3
  35. Kathy says:

    Not that I expect the Taco DOJ to do anything about it, or even the Spinless Party in Congress to hold hearings, but now we have proof.

    A whistleblower has disclosed a memo to the Associated Press which asserts “sweeping power to forcibly enter people’s homes without a judge’s warrant, according to an internal Immigration and Customs Enforcement memo obtained by The Associated Press,”

    More from the piece:

    The memo itself has not been widely shared within the agency, according to a whistleblower complaint, but its contents have been used to train new ICE officers who are being deployed into cities and towns to implement the president’s immigration crackdown. New ICE hires and those still in training are being told to follow the memo’s guidance instead of written training materials that actually contradict the memo, according to the whistleblower disclosure.

    Emphasis added.

    This clearly shows the higher functionaries who run ICE know their actions are illegal, but are undertaking them anyway.

    If the Democrats take the presidency in 2028, and there’s no immediate, full, and through investigation of the Taco regime, we may as well bury America alongside Rome and Persia.

    2