Wednesday’s Forum

OTB relies on its readers to support it. Please consider helping by becoming a monthly contributor through Patreon or making a one-time contribution via PayPal. Thanks for your consideration.

FILED UNDER: Open Forum
Steven L. Taylor
About Steven L. Taylor
Steven L. Taylor is a Professor Emeritus of Political Science and former College of Arts and Sciences Dean. His main areas of expertise include parties, elections, and the institutional design of democracies. His most recent book is the co-authored A Different Democracy: American Government in a 31-Country Perspective. He earned his Ph.D. from the University of Texas and his BA from the University of California, Irvine. He has been blogging since 2003 (originally at the now defunct Poliblog). Follow Steven on Twitter and/or BlueSky.

Comments

  1. charontwo says:

    DHS detention:

    Link

    1
  2. charontwo says:

    @charontwo:

    The Gaslight Report

    What you’re now watching in MAGA is Trump’s narcissistic collapse upscaled.

    When a pathological narcissist enters the stage of collapse, what little empathy existed disappears, projection intensifies, rage replaces strategy, and reality testing fails. Because MAGA identity is fused to him, his collapse isn’t just personal. It affects the group.

    The group mirrors his emotional state: paranoid, punitive, disinhibited.

    Trump didn’t create the hatred. It was there, festering and waiting. He removed restraints.

    He modeled sadistic mockery. He legitimized projection by posing as the victim while wielding power. And he collapsed the moral ceiling by replacing dog whistles with bullhorns.

    Once dehumanization is normalized at the top, no one below asks if it’s “too far.” That question has already been answered. MAGA sees that nothing is too far: blowing up fishermen, murdering protesters, trampling on the Constitution.

    Once fear and identity fuse around a leader, the next step is to convert permission into righteousness and advance the progression from fear to hate.

    Kristi Noem does more than get off on her new-found power.

    Her role is to take raw fear and harden it into hate by framing aggression as moral correctness.

    Her rhetoric repeatedly frames coercion as virtue and violence as purification. Cities must be “liberated.” Disorder must be “crushed.”

    Authoritarian systems have always relied on moral framing to turn brutality into duty. Hannah Arendt described this as the conversion of violence into ethical necessity. The follower is not violent, they’re demonstrating virtue.

    Noem’s language follows that template closely.

    9
  3. Scott says:

    WTF?

    FAA closes El Paso airspace for 10 days

    The Federal Aviation Administration issued notices late Tuesday, closing airspace over El Paso and a large patch of southern New Mexico west of Santa Teresa for 10 days. El Paso International Airport is closed to all flights, the city said.

    The orders close off all air travel in the affected area, which could cause massive disruption in the nation’s 23rd largest city.

    The notices, known as Notice to Air Missions, or NOTAM, took effect at 11:30 p.m. Mountain Time Tuesday, and expire at 11:30 p.m. Feb. 20. The announcement caught officials with local government agencies and Fort Bliss by surprise, multiple sources told El Paso Matters.

    “All air traffic has been halted in a 10 nautical mile range around the airport, so encompassing El Paso and Fort Bliss, from the ground to 17,000 feet. So no aircraft in or out, regardless of what they are, whether it’s air carriers, military, medevac helicopters, law enforcement. Nobody can fly as this thing is written up,” the person said.

    Closed for “Special security concerns” and Fort Bliss doesn’t know?

    1
  4. Michael Reynolds says:

    @charontwo:
    True. But there were no ubiquitous cameras in 1939, and there was no way for people to organize effectively. And there were no Minnesotans.

    3
  5. Scott says:

    As I suggested a month or so ago:

    Canada’s Muscular New Anti-Trump Strategy Debuts in Greenland

    At the top of a tall white pole that dwarfs a tiny red cottage on the edge of Greenland’s snow-capped western coastline, a brand-new flag flies in the Arctic air.

    On Friday, Canada’s consulate opened in the unassuming building, a permanent diplomatic outpost sharing modest digs with Iceland — previously one of the only countries with a formal presence in the territory.

    Opening a Canadian consulate in Nuuk, the capital of the autonomous territory of Greenland in the Kingdom of Denmark, has been in the works for over a year. But the timing, coinciding with both another round of menacing from U.S. President Donald Trump and bracing talk at Davos by Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney of the need to forge new alliances, is not lost on anyone here.

    No one ever listens to poor Scott, no, he’s quite mad, they say. It is good that Scott does not mind, has even grown to like it.

    5
  6. Jen says:

    @Scott: Even more WTF-ish, the FAA has just reversed that decision.

    ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

    3
  7. Gregory Lawrence Brown says:

    NPR Is reporting that FAA has reopened El Paso airspace.

    1
  8. Kathy says:

    I finished season 1 of Haunted Hotel on Netflix.

    The premise is, wait for it, a hotel haunted by ghosts and other supernatural creatures. It’s owned by a divorced woman with two kids, and her deceased brother, who is now a ghost.

    It was ok for an animated series, with some very funny moments. The one issue I see is it keeps veering off in different directions. The last ep, no spoilers, was rather good, except for the fact that one of the kids, Esther, never really developed the deep relationship with one of the hotel’s creatures that is shown in the ep, and which is crucial to the plot. Just two eps prior, their relationship consisted in acknowledging each other in passing, while engaged in separate dark magic endeavors.

    It’s ok for when you need a short watch after coming home too late from work.

    1
  9. Scott says:

    Lysenkoism continues on its rise.

    Prasad overruled FDA staff to reject Moderna’s flu vaccine application

    Top Food and Drug Administration official Vinay Prasad overruled the agency’s reviewers when he refused to accept Moderna’s application for a new influenza vaccine, STAT has learned.

    Three agency officials familiar with the matter told STAT that the team of career scientists was ready to review Moderna’s application, and that David Kaslow, the head of the vaccine office, wrote a detailed memo explaining why the FDA should embark on the review.

    3
  10. Beth says:

    As an attorney, nothing says “this IS what I went to law school for” , quite like beating a pro se litigant in court.

    2
  11. Michael Cain says:

    Bloomberg has reported that Trump will sign an executive order today directing US military bases to buy their electricity from coal-fired power plants. The order will also announce a plan to have the Dept of Energy spend $175M to upgrade coal-burning plants in several Appalachian states. No word on what those upgrades might be. Scrubbers? Capacity expansion?

    https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/trump-direct-pentagon-buy-coal-revive-industry-bloomberg-news-says-2026-02-11/

    1
  12. Scott says:

    All this is just a pissing contest?

    @Scott: @Jen: @Gregory Lawrence Brown:

    Airspace closure followed spat over drone-related tests and party balloon shoot-down, sources say

    The unexpected but brief airspace closure in the Texas border city of El Paso stemmed from disagreements between the Federal Aviation Administration and Pentagon officials over drone-related tests, multiple sources close to the matter told CBS News.

    The Pentagon had undertaken extensive planning on the use of military technology near Fort Bliss, a military base that abuts the El Paso International Airport, to practice taking down drones.

    Two sources identified the technology as a high-energy laser.

    Meetings were scheduled over safety impacts, but Pentagon officials wanted to test the technology sooner, stating that U.S. Code 130i requirements governing the protection of certain facilities from unmanned aircraft had been met.

    FAA Administrator Bryan Bedford on Tuesday night decided to close the airspace — without alerting White House, Pentagon or Homeland Security officials, sources said.

    Bedford told officials the airspace restrictions would be in place to ensure safety until issues with the War Department could be resolved.

    The FAA declined to comment.

    1
  13. Mikey says:

    @Scott: The Republican vision for America: sicker, poorer, and dumber.

    2
  14. Michael Reynolds says:

    The government has dramatically lowered its estimates for how many jobs the economy generated over the past two years.

    The Labor Department’s Bureau of Labor Statistics on Wednesday said that the U.S. added just 1.5 million jobs in 2024, well below the previously estimated 2 million. In 2025, it said the labor market added only 181,000 jobs, versus the previously estimated 584,000.

    Two separate revisions are mainly at play.

    So, Biden’s numbers are inflated by a third, and Trump’s numbers are inflated by 300%? One of these facts looks like bad statistics; the other one looks like a deliberate lie. And we’re supposed to believe the Trump regime’s claim for January? Why would we?

    9
  15. Lucys Football says:

    Wouldn”t be a surprise if it is true:
    Raskin says Trump’s name appears in the unredacted Epstein files over one million times: Report
    I also think the Democrats should strongly push for Lutnick to be removed as Commerce Secretary. He visited Epstein’s island when it was already known that he was a sex offender. They should go for a scalp.

    3
  16. Kathy says:

    The one “good” thing about coal, is that it tends to occur in higher concentrations than most other mineral ores. Therefore there’s less in the way of tailings (waste rocks) than in other kinds of mining.

    The bad thing about that “good” thing, is that it’s mined in such great quantities, that it produces much more tailings measured as mass than many other types of mining.

    I’m confident that absent some great disaster that wipes out civilization, and climate change may just do it, we’ll eventually move to 100% non carbon emitting energy sources. When that happy state of affairs is reached, we’ll still extract oil, albeit in smaller amounts, because it’s also used in a variety of chemical industries, and to make some materials, like plastics and asphalt.

    I don’t think there’s a corresponding use for coal. There are means for making gasoline out of coal, which requires hydrogenation, but in a non-carbon economy that would hardly be necessary.

    2
  17. Kathy says:

    @Michael Reynolds:

    Last year the wingnuts claimed the drops in job numbers reflected immigrants who were deported, detained, or otherwise left their jobs.

    How much food an health insurance can an unemployed person buy with deportation and detention statistics?

    1
  18. Gustopher says:

    https://thehill.com/homenews/media/5733236-gallup-stops-presidential-approval-ratings-polls/

    I guess the URL is pretty much the entire article, minus the excuses. Gallup is stopping the presidential approval ratings poll after 80 years.

    Well, for the next few years I guess we can just keep saying that according to the latest Gallup poll, Trump’s approval is 41%.

    4
  19. Kathy says:

    Looking at this photo of Lindsey Vonn in the hospital, three thoughts came to mind:

    1) that’s a lot of IV medication (4 working visible infusion pumps, presumably more on an IV tree on her left side). Likely pain medication and antibiotics.

    2) the supports on her leg look damned uncomfortable (and likely why she needs pain meds).

    3) poor woman almost certainly has a urinary catheter.

    2
  20. dazedandconfused says:

    @Scott: Yes.

    A pissing match between the FAA (being currently run by someone who is more or less competent) and the Pentagon (being run by a Kegseth, an arrogant drunken frat boy).

    There are conflicts like this around all military stations that put stuff up in the air, in normal times settled between two adults without anybody hearing about it. Every time there is a space shot, Air Force One goes by, the Blue Angels or Thunderbirds are doing a show, and the proximity fused AA shell tests that happen around Yakima (from personal knowledge) for a few examples.

    This time the Pentagon seems to have tried to tell the FAA they will be using their lasers near commercial traffic without bothering to negotiate with the FAA. The head of the FAA apparently decided the best way to educate them, to show them “that shit isn’t going to fly”…as it were, was to raise a ruckus. I strongly suspect he encountered an arrogance which is new to the Pentagon before making that decision.

    4
  21. Kathy says:

    @Gustopher:

    I found the news surprising, but thinking further about it, perhaps not that surprising.

    When the electorate is so polarized, it would make sense for a majority of GOP voters to disapprove of a Democratic incumbent regardless of what they do in office, or how these voters are affected by their policies.

    I’d argue the reverse is also true, but it’s hard to contend with El Taco. Seen objectively, I can’t think of one good, sensible, rational, or necessary policy he’s implemented in this term, and none come to mind for his first one, either. Certainly none through the pandemic, 2020 election, and worse yet the election’s aftermath. I can think of a few in Bush the toddler’s terms.

    Either way, if 40% or so of those polled will give a negative rating regardless of other factors, then maybe the numbers the poll produces are not very useful.

    3
  22. Michael Cain says:

    @Kathy: Metallurgical coal (as opposed to thermal coal) will probably hang on for quite some time for ironmaking. New processes with much lower CO2 emissions are coming along, but depend on large stocks of green hydrogen.

    1
  23. dazedandconfused says:

    @Kathy:

    About half of Gallup’s funding coming from governmental agencies…and Trump’s love for beating people into submission whenever he can…is probably what’s behind it.

    4
  24. Kathy says:

    @Michael Cain:

    I’m guessing that would be coal added to metal alloys, like carbon steel, not coal used to power furnaces to melt iron and other metals.

    1
  25. Kathy says:

    On the bad news front today, we may be far closer to a climate tipping point.

    Spring seems to come earlier every year. I remember when cold/cool weather persisted until early to mid-March. Now it’s more like mid-February. Today was positively warm by 10 am. It may be a fluke, or maybe winter ended over 5 weeks ahead of schedule.

    Even worse news, reading and writing can lower the risk of dementia up to 38%.

    Great. So the climate will turn hellish, and I’m more likely to be fully aware of it when it happens.

    Maybe I should watch more TV.

  26. Eusebio says:

    @Kathy:
    It’s quite an illustration of the risk-reward balance that’s made Lindsey Vonn oft injured and also the greatest downhill racer of all time.

    1
  27. Richard Gardner says:

    @Kathy: Given your location (CDMX) I could equally ask if it is an urban heat island. Likewise in much of the world after WW II rivers have been dammed for irrigation and flood control, massively changing the humidity levels in the “dry” season with evaporation (and heat content (enthalpy)) = nights don’t get as cold so starting off at a higher temp the next day (greenery too, lawns). Blaming everything on CO2 is simplistic (yes, CO2 is a factor, but so is water vapor (humidity)).

    I do have an engineering background in Thermodynamics (I’m rusty but could do steam cycle calcs in my head within 10% of a formal check the Mollier Chart numbers), and even took a course (calculus-based) in atmospheric thermodynamics – well before it was trendy.

    The Trump coal fetish – well I’ve given my opinion.

    1