Source: The White House

Revisiting McCarthy’s Claim About the GOP

4

Comments

So, I was thinking about this quote from Kevin McCarthy’s quote regarding the Democrats and Graham Planter.

Kevin McCarthy on Platner Allegations: That one thing I know about Republicans is when we had a very bad candidate, we didn't vote for that person. We walked away.

Acyn (@acyn.bsky.social) 2026-07-07T00:19:33.384Z

Why was I thinking about it? Well…

CNBC reports: Max Miller stays in Ohio House race as GOP ballot deadline passes.

Republican Rep. Max Miller of Ohio will remain in his reelection race, after a key deadline passed for the GOP to replace him as its nominee, despite mounting calls from fellow Republicans for him to drop his reelection bid.

Under Ohio law, Republicans have until Monday at 4 p.m. to name a replacement nominee. But the local Republican officials responsible for choosing one must receive at least two days’ notice before meeting, meaning Miller would have needed to withdraw by Saturday for the party to complete the process in time. He did not.

Miller has now effectively missed the deadline, but could still withdraw and have his name removed from the ballot. Republicans would then be left without a nominee in Ohio’s 7th Congressional District.

Miller’s spokesperson did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

The deadline passed after a week of escalating Republican pressure on Miller to step aside over claims from his ex-wife, Emily Moreno, that he physically abused her and their young daughter. Miller has denied the allegations.

Miller’s father-in-law, Republican Sen. Bernie Moreno of Ohio, called the incumbent “a danger” last weekend and urged him to resign. Republican Sen. Jon Husted of Ohio later joined calls for Miller to leave office and end his campaign.

And what of GOP leaders?

President Donald Trump and House Speaker Mike Johnson, R-La., have stood by Miller.

Imagine that.

I would note that Miller is credibly accused of behavior that outstrips Platners.

Indeed, he sounds like a thoroughly awful human being.

To wit, as reported by Mother Jones: Rep. Max Miller Has a History of Withholding His Daughter’s Blue Bunny and Police Footage Shows Rep. Max Miller Downplaying His Daughter’s Broken Collarbone.

From the second link:

The report was based on more than 2,000 pages of court filings and police records, including a 48-page investigatory file relating to possible child abuse after their toddler experienced a broken collarbone. This file included numerous troubling allegations from Emily Moreno—Miller’s ex-wife and the daughter of US Sen. Bernie Moreno—who accused Miller of throwing scalding water at her, shoving her against a wall during a heated custody exchange, and holding a gun to her head while she was trying to change their daughter’s diaper. Other public records accused Miller of drug abuse and threatening behavior.

[…]

the clips we are publishing show a child protection specialist indicating the collarbone injury was accompanied by a bruise resembling a handprint. Emily Moreno also tells police that their daughter expressed fear of her father.

This week, Sen. Moreno weighed in on the personal drama roiling his family, calling it the “seventh circle of hell.”

“My daughter lives in constant fear of this man,” Sen. Moreno continued.

Meanwhile…

Q: Dems ditched Graham Platner after sexual assault allegations. Two members of your conference — Max Miller and Cory Mills — face domestic violence allegations. Why keep them in the conference?MIKE JOHNSON: The key word there is 'allegation'

Aaron Rupar (@atrupar.com) 2026-07-21T14:51:27.775Z

Mike Johnson defends Max Miller despite horrible abuse allegations: "We don't take disciplinary action against members for allegations. It's in his own words 'a nasty divorce proceeding' … he thinks it's a hit job on him."

Aaron Rupar (@atrupar.com) 2026-08-07T13:19:35.423Z

Also:

A real profile in courage!

Yes, when it comes to the criminal justice system, people deserve due process. But when allegations rise to a certain level (which I think have been surpassed in this case, as they were in the Platner situation), parties are within their rights to decide whom they want to bear their labels. Or, certainly, leaders are fully within their rights to make public condemnations, even if they lack the power to remove a candidate. You are, after all, known by the company you keep.

I would note that that aphorism is an increasingly damning one for the GOP.

4 responses to “Revisiting McCarthy’s Claim About the GOP”

  1. We’re one to fairly tote up scandals, sexual, financial, whatever, I believe you would find the GOP side of the ledger much longer and more serious than the D side. Even if you left Trump and his family off. Can anyone even conceive of a Dem comparable to Ken Paxton?

    And harking back to my comment on your Douthat post, were one to similarly tote up people who have been punished for what they said, I believe the list of oppression by GOPs would dwarf any oppression by the left. The left criticizing someone for racism or boycotting a speech doesn’t balance firing someone for noting post mortem that Charlie Kirk was an asshole.

    2
  2. One of the defining relationships of fascism is lawlessness. The legal system exists to protect those on one side, regardless of what crimes they commit, since they are the preferred class of people and loyal to the movement. Everyone else receives the hammer, when the authorities deem it necessary, or just randomly. Legal protections for me, but not for thee.

    Another trait of fascism is the alliance of misfits, cynical opportunists, kooks, zealots, liars, incompetents, and degenerates that populates a big part of the movement. These are the people who could find no home in normal political times, but find common cause with each other. While people like Max Miller, Stephen Miller, Victor Marx, Corey Lewandowski, Peter Thiel, RFK Jr., et al. might not have been compatriots in 2020, MAGA has given them the big tent where they can all co-exist and prosper.

    2
    1. One of the defining relationships of fascism is lawlessness. The legal system exists to protect those on one side, regardless of what crimes they commit, since they are the preferred class of people and loyal to the movement. Everyone else receives the hammer, when the authorities deem it necessary, or just randomly. Legal protections for me, but not for thee.

      Your description of fascism echoes Wilhoit’s Law, which was offered as a description of the current existing U. S. Depressing.

  3. Charley in Cleveland Avatar
    Charley in Cleveland

    The willful blindness of McCarthy to Trump’s degeneracy, and Johnson’s newly found allegiance to due process (allegations!) in Max Miller’s case, reveals yet another layer of the astounding hypocrisy of the Republican party. Trump’s mental illness is a defense for him, but what’s up with McCarthy and Johnson and the rest of the Trump enablers? When a POS like Bernie Moreno* says Max Miller is a POS, maybe other Republicans should listen.

    *Moreno was unknown outside of Ohio until his F-bombing cos-play in the Fauci “hearing.”