Thursday’s Forum
Steven L. Taylor
·
Thursday, February 19, 2026
·
38 comments
OTB relies on its readers to support it. Please consider helping by becoming a monthly contributor through Patreon or making a one-time contribution via PayPal. Thanks for your consideration.
About Steven L. Taylor
Steven L. Taylor is a Professor Emeritus of Political Science and former College of Arts and Sciences Dean. His main areas of expertise include parties, elections, and the institutional design of democracies. His most recent book is the co-authored
A Different Democracy: American Government in a 31-Country Perspective. He earned his Ph.D. from the University of Texas and his BA from the University of California, Irvine. He has been blogging since 2003 (originally at the now defunct Poliblog).
Follow Steven on
Twitter and/or
BlueSky.
Following up on yesterday’s post on Canada’s defense plans:
Canadians kind of hate America now. Our new poll shows just how much.
This makes me profoundly sad. Our family has many connections with Canada: vacations, cemeteries, cousins. They are family.
Hegseth invites Christian Nationalist pastor Doug Wilson to lead prayers at the Pentagon. Among his stated opinions, Wilson believes women shouldn’t vote, and slavery was often hunky-dory.
https://www.military.com/daily-news/2026/02/18/who-doug-wilson-pentagon-defends-pastor-who-led-christian-prayer-service.html
Chris Tomlinson is one of my favorite local columnists. The Texas Republican Party is going full Klan this election season.
Texans don’t prejudge Christians for sex scandals. They owe Muslims the same respect.
There’s more but the writing is succinct and pointed.
In my humble theological opinion:
Christian Nationalism = White Nationalism = Satanism
I get a morning newsletter from Punchbowl News. Sort of a gossipy, navel gazing Washington product dedicated to politics. They seem to be obsessed with following the money. Here is a succinct summary:
@Scott:
Not surprising that 58% of Canadian adults “disagree that the United States is a reliable ally,” based on what I think the words is and reliable mean. I might’ve expected the number to be higher.
While El Taco assembles the largest concentration of offensive air power in the Middle East since 2003, he also holds a meeting for his board of peace.
George Orwell couldn’t be reached for comment.
@Scott:
If they spent more on wages and benefits for their employees, they wouldn’t need to buy elections.
Well, good morning. Waking to a really cheery list of comments so far at the Forum. How do Trump supporters not recognize that this stuff is nuts?
The answer is largely FOX “News”.
CNN: Trump administration expands ICE’s ability to detain legal refugees in latest memo.
Apparently if the administration can’t issue a green card to a legal refugee because of the government’s backlog, you can be placed in Trump’s concentration camp for ????
https://www.cnn.com/2026/02/19/politics/trump-refugees-memo-detain-immigration-hnk
Reading articles today about how the US military is almost in place for a potential strike on Iran, and they’re just waiting for Trump to decide what to do. I can’t imagine a dumber timeline.
@gVOR10:
i don’t think it’s largely Fox News; I think it’s dispositional on the part of the enthusiastic Trumpkins. I recall reading a fascinating article shortly after the 2016 election reporting that in Mississippi there were considerable numbers of men and women in their forties and fifties who had never voted before. But they came out in droves to vote for Trump. Clearly they were ultra-low news consumers, even of Fox.
I just finished doing something with the bank, which included opening an account. In the old days, assuming you were close to a branch office, this might have taken 60-90 minutes, including travel time.
In these new, efficient, days of cell phones and apps, it took only 120 minutes over two days.
@Kathy:
I know right. The first thing on the agenda of the “Bord of Peace” is whether or not to bomb Iran.
@Rick DeMent:
We passed Ignorance is Strength a while ago. Now we’ve reached War is Peace.
As soon as they realize they need the immigrant workers they’ve detained and deported, we’ll complete the trifecta one way or another.
@CSK: Yesterday I stumbled across a Substack with an interesting explanation of Trump, abusive child rearing.
The writer quotes some respected authorities on fascism stating the same theory. I’m a bit unconvinced this is a major factor, but that may be because I’m naive about how many families have practiced “strict father” abusive childrearing.
@Kathy:
Ignorance is Peace.
Streaming our local news is so depressing. Every other ad is promoting online gaming or sports betting. Lots of the gambling games are directed at kids. Colorful cartoon animals and kiddie voices, with promises of super easy money. Seedy and sleazy as all get out.
Unfortunately, lotteries and gambling have, over time, been become cash cows for states, replacing other more progressive taxes.And gambling addictions are ruining a lot of young men, according to Dave Ramsey, the Christian conservative financial advisor. On this issue, I’m with him.
Between all the crypto scams and prediction markets, it’s more like living on Pleasure Island instead of America. The enshittification of America continues apace.
@gVOR10:
Back around the time I moved to TX, 1988ish, there was a movement to end school spanking. It was unsuccessful, a majority of TX voters liked having the schools cleared to spank their kids.
My guess is school spanking is or was culturally typical in the states of the old Confederacy.
@CSK:
I think this is a lot of it, not just for enthusiastic Trump supporters, but for Conservatives writ large. Dispositional, with reinforcing “programming” from Fox News.
My father in law is a good example. He’s not an enthusiastic Trump supporter, but he’s a supporter anyway. He’s got a black grandchild, a daughter married to a trans (that fled the country), and he’s from MN. He fundamentally refuses to admit that things are fucked and that the GOP is responsible for it.
I work/ed with and around a bunch of different real estate developers. I had direct exposure to real estate developers and contractors. Almost uniformly they were some of the absolute dumbest people I have ever met. But they were great at selling things and great at moving money around to keep the operation afloat until bullshit debt* caught up to them. When I explained this to my father in law, he absolutely refused to believe me, because 1. I am an idiot child and not his equal (I was in my 40’s and had been a lawyer for at least 10 years), and 2. real estate developers have money so that means they are smart. #1. was probably the most important reason why he will never believe me.
@gVOR10:
As a person who grew up an an abusive home and deals with C-PSTD daily, this theory sounds very plausible to me.
The version I got was everyone is mad at me, at all times. That everything I do is wrong. Not only wrong, but stupid, so stupid that I shouldn’t even try. I think I posted a DJ mix I made here a couple weeks ago. Getting to the point of doing that took an enormous, painful, effort on my part to get through the programming of my parents. It was so hard, that my brain is actively trying to talk me out of doing it again. I have an idea of what happened to me**, I have been through a shit load of therapy, and I will battle against the ghosts of my parents for the rest of my life.
If someone has been programmed by their parents like in the quote above, and which I believe is very common, if they don’t actively try to heal, nothing will get better for us. The only grace we’ll get is that Trump will die and the rest of those freaks don’t have the juice to take over from him.
They’re all convinced they do, but that’s cause they’re dispositionally dipshits.
*Like Tech Debt, but for bullshitting dipshits.
**One thing childhood trauma does is make swiss cheese out of my memory. The only way for me to understand my childhood is through a sort of gravitational lensing of how I react to things now.
@gVOR10:
I’m wondering if the families that produce Trump voters (the parents as well will be Trumpkins) is more a form of very specific verbal abuse: i.e. the parents repeatedly telling the kids that they don’t have any friends, that all people outside the family represent some sort of danger.
@Scott: Perhaps this is because Sharia law doesn’t condone ministers sexually abusing children contrary to their experience of current state law.
@gVOR10: The details may vary, but I am certain this has so much to do with it. The people from my youth that I identify with the worst sort of authoritarian upbringing are also those who are the most vocal and strident Trump supporters.
One aspect of this is how little able they are to tolerate uncertainty. Which I expect means that when this falls apart, it will fall hard.
EXCEPT, some of them have walked away, they have engaged in a healing process and seek to do things a different way. So, nothing is fixed in stone.
I observed rigorous masking during the trump pandemic, and managed not to catch the trump virus all that time, and for years after vaccination as well. I’ve kept masking, less rigorously, since then as a means of avoiding the common cold and flu. I pretty much wear a mask at work, and whenever I go out.
I still managed to catch cold, about twice a year, since 2024.
So, what gives?
I concluded I avoided COVID more through a mixture of luck and the general other precautions put in place, like distancing, more people masking, less people around overall, etc.
And yet, over the past two weeks, about half the people in our area caught a particularly nasty variety of cold, including two who sit close to my place, and I’ve avoided it.
Seeing others who don’t wear masks did too, I can’t credit continued masking. But it’s nice not to be stricken with it while Hell Week marches on.
I suppose one possibility is they caught a more recent COVID variant. I’ve had the yearly shots since 2023 (though due to work I’ve delayed this year’s shot), so I’m probably better protected against it.
Who the hell knows. I can’t exactly run a double blind trial at the office…
Next day after next day reply to @Kathy
My personal opinion (for what little that may be worth), given no major US land forces or amphibious groups are moving, is the Administration/Pentagon has no intention of taking Iran.
Assuuming they have anything resembling a coherent plan, it will probably be to dismember Iranian government and military command structures, communications, and leadership targets.
Destroy both ofeensive and defensive missile sites and stocks.
And to hit various missile production and nuclear related stuff.
The calculation might be that sufficient regime degradation can produce a revolt/civil war, while the US just watches from the sidelines.
Of course it might be possible that Trump might address the nation, and set out his reasons and objectives in regard to a major military operation. Or more likely, not.
Or adress Congress for a vote of support?
I suspect we”ll see pigs flying over Iran before that happens.
Anyway, the Ford is now heading through the Med fast enough to make a speedboat blush.
Should turn up near Cyprus around Sunday morning, at present speed.
The question then is, does it turn for Suez, or take station off the Israeli coast?
Once it’s got to wherever its heading, be that eastern Med or a transit of Red Sea (which will add a week or so) then its a matter of days to a couple of weeks before either Iran caves, Trump backs off, or the shooting starts.
Sustaining the current scale of land-based aircraft in the area for much longer is likely to become problematic, given the level of maintenance and support involved.
@JohnSF: There is a clear possibility it’s just classic gunboat diplomacy, and Trump only wants a “deal” of some kind as another trophy. If so it would be wise for the Iranians to play along so they probably will. If they don’t Trump will lob some bombs in there so he can instead brag he obliterated something, a consolation prize for his ego, but that’s about it.
Under the heading of “Things that make you go hmmmm…”
@JohnSF:
Of course! That’s the US way, war in the Middle East on the cheap. It’s worked great for 70+ years.
@Beth:
Wheter such a plan would actually work is very doubtful
But i suspect that’s what they are thinking.
tbf, at least they don’t seems to be quite crazy enough to plan a land war in Iran.
Yet.
@dazedandconfused:
Could be just display to force concession.
Which may depend on exactly what the message conveyed at Geneva about US demands were.
Oddly enough, that’s not clear at all.
But imho there’s way too much firepower being concentrated for this not be deadly serious.
What could and would Iran offer to buy off Trump?
And what would Trump accept as making him look like “a winner”?
The problem is, things like this often develop a momentum of their own.
@JohnSF:
I think there’s enough institutional knowledge and practice in the Pentagon to ensure some kind of rational, workable plan for a range of attacks on Iran.
In the early Tom Clancy books, Jack Ryan notes divining the Soviets’ intentions was particularly hard, because all too often the Soviets themselves ha no idea what they intended to do. Neither does El Taco.
So, how much use are war plans when the taco making the decisions changes what passes for his mind on an hourly basis. he’s as likely to unleash a devastating attack on Iran, as he is to be exchanging love letters with the top ayatollah.
Even without a land war, toppling the government could cause years of civil war as various factions fight for power, not to mention foreign actors who’d meddle. One thinks the Gulf monarchies would want to control the scary neighbor to the north.
@JohnSF: @dazedandconfused: I will be watching the underlying reaction of the working class MAGA crowd to any serious action in Iran. After all, Trump got votes in response to the 20-30 years of adventures and deaths in Iraq/Afghanistan. The Iran adventure seems to be directly contradicting those instincts.
“Dropsite”
Some excerpts, very long piece:
…
…
…
And the Israelis:
“Oren”
A thought of mine: Trump and Hegseth seem to enjoy violence as entertainment, and I think they both get off on hurting or killing people.
ETA: The gulf arabs and Saudis would need to be making their airspace available for this to happen, which implies they think Iran attempts at retaliation against them would not succeed.
Oil stocks and oil related stocks had big gains today.
@charontwo:
He might be right for all I know, but Daniel Davis has no record of being in military intelligence, that think-tank is a Ron Paul org, and Davis has a youtube channel which features crackpots like Larry Johnson. He tries to do his own thinking which is commendable, but I wouldn’t put a lot of bank on what he says. Not an “insider”.
@JohnSF: But in the matter of trying to intimidate someone can there such a thing as a display of too much power?
Big Taco is watching you.
Seriously, how long are you going to put up with this shit?
@dazedandconfused:
References? (Ron Paul, etc.)?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drop_Site_News
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daniel_L._Davis
@charontwo: Defense Priorities is the think tank I was referring to. Strong links between them and Ron. NTTAWWT, libertarians have some good thoughts, but like most ideologies their takes tend to be skewed and tunnel-visioned.
I wandered in to Davis’s youtube channel in a matter involving the war in Ukraine a few months back. Haven’t bothered to do so again. Not that what the guy thought was all wrong, I merely deemed it shallow.
@JohnSF:
The last Iranian revolution worked out so well for us.
Under Obama a lot of people here and abroad worked out a deal to curtail Iran’s nuclear development. An agreement Trump 1.0 just walked away from. All those people must be banging their heads on their desks right now.