Wednesday’s Forum

OTB relies on its readers to support it. Please consider helping by becoming a monthly contributor through Patreon or making a one-time contribution via PayPal. Thanks for your consideration.

FILED UNDER: Open Forum
Steven L. Taylor
About Steven L. Taylor
Steven L. Taylor is a Professor Emeritus of Political Science and former College of Arts and Sciences Dean. His main areas of expertise include parties, elections, and the institutional design of democracies. His most recent book is the co-authored A Different Democracy: American Government in a 31-Country Perspective. He earned his Ph.D. from the University of Texas and his BA from the University of California, Irvine. He has been blogging since 2003 (originally at the now defunct Poliblog). Follow Steven on Twitter and/or BlueSky.

Comments

  1. Bill Jempty says:

    Actor Val Kilmer has passed away. He was 65*. RIP.

    *- I was surprised to learn he is older than me.

  2. Beth says:

    I am so sick of men not listening to me. I just had a man confidently waste £16 of mine because he wouldn’t listen. I know that my kids are entitled to discounted fares. I wanted to get two full freight Oyster cards because it’s not worth my time to constantly get new discounted tickets each fucking day. We should have an apartment within days and we can get started on the discount cards then.

    My kids are about to be dumped out into an entirely new life. I just want to make it slightly easier on all of us. The marginal extra cost fine.

    The best part was his idiotic happiness as he totally disregarded both what I was saying and the “I’m going to choke you face.”

    5
  3. Daryl says:

    @Bill Jempty:
    Presaged in “Top Gun; Maverick”
    Poor guy had a tough go of it
    RIP

  4. Bill Jempty says:
  5. Bill Jempty says:

    @Daryl: I never watched Top Gun.

    1
  6. Bill Jempty says:

    @Beth:

    I am so sick of men not listening to me. I just had a man confidently waste £16 of mine because he wouldn’t listen.

    My sometime editor Leeanne once said. “Men- You can’t live with them. You can’t shoot them.”

    5
  7. Beth says:

    @Bill Jempty:

    I’d settle for a Taser.

    8
  8. Scott says:

    Tuesday’s Texas measles outbreak:

    The Texas Department of State Health Services is reporting an outbreak of measles in the South Plains and Panhandle regions of Texas. At this time, 422 cases have been identified since late January. Forty-two of the patients have been hospitalized.

    There have been 6 other cases in Texas in 2025 but those have been associated with international travel.

    New Mexico: Now up to 48 cases. Up 1 case from last week.

    Measles tracker: Follow cases, outbreaks and vaccination rates across the U.S.

    Handy nationwide tracker. Measles across the US.

    1
  9. Charley in Cleveland says:

    ANNOUNCER: This episode of measles is brought to you by Donald J. Trump and Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. As Jack Reacher said, “Remember…you asked for this.”

    9
  10. Daryl says:

    Looks like Musk could buy Trump for $1/4B but not Wisconsin with his $20M and a cheesehead hat.
    I’m going to Wisconsin, and Road America, at the end of May and I’ll gladly spend my tourism dollars there, now.

    5
  11. Scott says:

    Really, what did anyone expect?

    US officials object to European push to buy weapons locally

    U.S. officials have told European allies they want them to keep buying American-made arms, amid recent moves by the European Union to limit U.S. manufacturers’ participation in weapons tenders, five sources familiar with the matter told Reuters.

    The messages delivered by Washington in recent weeks come as the EU takes steps to boost Europe’s weapons industry, while potentially limiting purchases of certain types of U.S. arms.

    In a March 25 meeting, Secretary of State Marco Rubio told the foreign ministers of Lithuania, Latvia and Estonia that the United States wants to continue participating in EU countries’ defense procurements, the sources told Reuters.

    4
  12. just nutha says:

    @Bill Jempty: You didn’t miss anything.

    1
  13. charontwo says:

    Atlantic piece on Project 2025:

    Gift link:

    Gift

    “Freedom is a fragile thing, and it’s never more than one generation away from extinction,” Ronald Reagan said in 1967, in his inaugural address as governor of California. Kevin D. Roberts, the president of the Heritage Foundation, approvingly quotes the speech in his foreword to Project 2025, the conservative think tank’s blueprint for the Trump administration. Roberts writes that the plan has four goals for protecting its vision of freedom: restoring the family “as the centerpiece of American life”; dismantling the federal bureaucracy; defending U.S. “sovereignty, borders, and bounty”; and securing “our God-given individual rights to live freely.”

    Project 2025 has proved to be a good road map for understanding the first months of Donald Trump’s second term, but most of the focus has been on efforts to dismantle the federal government as we know it. The effort to restore traditional families has been less prominent so far, but it could reshape the everyday lives of all Americans in fundamental ways. Its place atop the list of priorities is no accident—it reflects the most deeply held views of many of the contributors—though the destruction of the administrative state might end up imperiling the Trump team’s ability to actually carry out the changes the authors want.

    A focus on heterosexual, married, procreating couples is everywhere in Project 2025. “Families comprised of a married mother, father, and their children are the foundation of a well-­ordered nation and healthy society,” writes Roger Severino, the author of a chapter on the Department of Health and Human Services and a former HHS and Justice Department staffer. (The document is structured as a series of chapters on specific departments or agencies, each written by one or a few authors.) He argues that the federal government should bolster organizations that “maintain a biblically based, social-­science-reinforced definition of marriage and family,” saying that other forms are less stable. The goal is not only moral; he and other authors see this as a path to financial stability and perhaps even greater prosperity for families.

    Project 2025’s authors identify a range of ways to achieve the goal across the executive branch. Changes to rules for 401(k)s and other savings programs would be more generous to married couples. HHS would enlist churches and other faith-­based organizations to “provide marriage and parenting guidance for low-­income fathers” that would “affirm and teach” based on “a biological and sociological understanding of what it means to be a father—­not a gender-neutral parent—­from social science, psychology, personal testimonies, etc.” Through educational programs, tax incentives, and other methods, the child-support system “should strengthen marriage as the norm, restore broken homes, and encourage unmarried couples to commit to marriage.” Temporary Assistance for Needy Families, the lead federal welfare program, would track statistics about “marriage, healthy family formation, and delaying sex to prevent pregnancy.”

    In this vision, men are breadwinners and women are mothers. “Without women, there are no children, and society cannot continue,” Max Primorac writes in his chapter on USAID, where he served in the first Trump administration. (Primorac calls for ridding the agency of “woke” politics and using it as an instrument of U.S. policy, but not the complete shutdown Trump has attempted.)

    Etc. all consistent with the culture war stuff the GOP is so obsessed with.

    2
  14. becca says:

    The MidSouth is predicted to get “generational “ flooding and strong tornadoes over the next few days. Memphis in the bullseye. 10-12 inches of rain and large hail. The weather service is warning not to assume areas that haven’t flooded in the past will not flood in this environment.
    Hellzapoppin’!

    2
  15. JohnSF says:

    @Scott:
    Predicted things predictably happen as predicted.

    European arms makers like a pay-day as much as the next guy; as do European politicians with arms related activity in their constituencies.
    The bigger the budget, the more interesting the menu is.

    3
  16. Beth says:

    @Scott:
    @JohnSF:

    Whoops, looks like the GOP accidentally killed the one thing that Americans actually make. So much greatness. Soon it’s just gonna be movies and Sprite you can actually drink.

    3
  17. Michael Reynolds says:

    @charontwo:

    restoring the family “as the centerpiece of American life

    How many men can support a family on a single income? Would it be, damn few? How many women are willing to ignore their education and skillset to stay at home and make casseroles? Would that also be damn few? What happens to the economy if we magically remove women from the workplace and push them back into the home? Are we going to suddenly find a way to make children an economic benefit rather than a burden?

    These people are morons.

    5
  18. Kathy says:

    @Scott:
    @JohnSF:
    @Beth:

    Considering many European countries might conceivably face US forces, no way in hell should they trust US arms not to have some kind of back door, some means to be jammed, etc. Maybe not the dumb iron bombs and shells, but possible with guided weapons, and especially aircraft (though the F-14s Iran may still have work just well except for a lack of spare parts).

    All aside the very natural impulse to 1) keep the money in their one countries or at least dependable allies, and 2) not to send more money to a potential rival/hostile country.

    Just because the felon has a chief nazi to hobble his country, doesn’t mean everyone else should follow suit.

    3
  19. Beth says:

    @Michael Reynolds:

    Are we going to suddenly find a way to make children an economic benefit rather than a burden?

    Wherever the GOP goes, awful plans follow.

    Now is probably a great time to hold on to real estate in CA, IL, NY and MA. Those places won’t change their child labor laws to turn kids into slaves for farmers. Once people realize that their kids won’t get educated they’ll either leave or rejoice. The rejoicers will end up stupider and poorer.

    Between that and Climate change, the Confederacy is going to become uninhabitable.

    3
  20. Flat Earth Luddite says:

    @Beth:

    Personally, Luddite suggests a cattle prod to the groin. Or the throat. But then again, Luddite’s not a nice sociopath.

    OTOH, I do make a nice ‘spro.

    3
  21. Jen says:

    @becca: Stay safe, and check in when you can. Flooding is no joke.

    2
  22. Neil Hudelson says:

    @becca:

    Tennessee’s about to be the testcase for what happens when you decimate FEMA staff.

    If I had to guess, Memphis and its surrounding area voted pretty hard against Fascism. As has been the case so often, those getting hurt the most are the ones who stood strong against Trump.

    Stay safe, friend, and let the OTB community know how we can help during the recovery.

    2
  23. CSK says:

    @becca:

    Please keep us posted about your well-being.

    2
  24. Michael Reynolds says:

    We may be having a real(ish) war shortly – an attack on Iran is likely. Trump says he wants talks with the Ayatollahs, but we had a deal with Iran (the JCPOA) which Trump unilaterally abrogated. So they should trust him now? We’ll have to see just how suicidal Iran’s government is. Between Israel’s attacks on Hezbollah and Hamas, and the US attacks on the Houthis, the Ayatollahs may decide on a prudent stand-down with hopes of rebuilding, or they may be feeling apocalyptic, in which case, bombs away.

    I have no objection in principle to taking out Iran’s nuclear weapons facilities. I’d rather do it when we had someone competent in the WH and the Pentagon. And I do wonder if Iran has some as-yet-unrevealed means for an asymmetric counterattack. Interestingly, there are stories that the KSA has whispered to Iran that they’re taking no part in this if it kicks off.

    Simultaneously, Israel (our ally) gets ready to confront Turkey (our NATO ally) both using American weapons, in a fight over Syria. Why the hell Israel is freaking out over Turkey is beyond me. What’s the better alternative for Syria?

    Meanwhile the PLAN (China’s Navy) has basically surrounded Taiwan in a very large ‘drill.’

    Bullied by Putin and Xi Trump may need a war with Iran just to look like less of a beta cuck soy boy.

    1
  25. gVOR10 says:

    @Michael Reynolds:

    I have no objection in principle to taking out Iran’s nuclear weapons facilities.

    I have only weak objections in principle, pre-emptive attack, civilian casualties, consideration of alternatives. But in practice it sounds like Iran has done a pretty thorough job of dispersing and hardening their facilities. A strike may be more provocative than effective.

    Bullied by Putin and Xi Trump may need a war with Iran just to look like less of a beta cuck soy boy.

    I don’t think Trump will deliberately start a war. He’ll fall into one through bungling and confusion.

    3
  26. JohnSF says:

    @gVOR10:
    Some aspects of a nuclear weapons production chain are in principle not amenable to dispersal.
    And hardening only gets you so far, when you talking about some units with rather massive power demands.
    It’s not easy, or necessarily the best option, but it is probably do-able.

    What remains to be seen is how Trump’s mercurial (to put it mildly) nature can deal with this issue.
    It would probably be a lot more manageable if Trump’s clumsy diplomacy and enabling Netanyahu’s proclivity for military action as a solution to all his political problems had not pissed off almost every other state in the region and beyond.

    Also, just how far into the administration communications various foreign intelligence agencies have now penetrated.

    2
  27. Kathy says:

    @Michael Reynolds:

    Quick aside, the formal name for China’s Navy is the People’s Liberation Army Navy I find it hilarious.

    Dead serious, too.

  28. Michael Cain says:

    @Kathy: Even more amusing is the People’s Liberation Army Naval Air Force.

  29. Michael Cain says:

    @becca: Try to stay safe. I was just looking at the GOES satellite loop for the last few hours and the storm is blowing up scary fast. Worst is currently in Arkansas/Missouri, but moving east.

    1
  30. CSK says:

    Oscar Arias Sanchez, Nobel Peace Prize winner and former president of Costa Rica, has had his visa revoked by Trump.

    Sanchez has criticized Trump. I gather Donald’s feelings were hurt.

    2
  31. Rob1 says:

    @charontwo:

    Freedom is a fragile thing, and it’s never more than one generation away from extinction,” Ronald Reagan said in 1967 [..]

    A focus on heterosexual, married, procreating couples is everywhere in Project 2025. “Families comprised of a married mother, father, and their children are the foundation of a well-­ordered nation and healthy society,” writes Roger Severino

    Freedom to think and be exactly like me!!!!

    “Freedom” in America is a blank slate upon which the politically ambitious can project their insincerity and obscure their true ambitions from the incurious.

    1
  32. Gustopher says:

    @Rob1: When you start considering the alternatives to heterosexual, married, procreating couples you start getting things like billionaires having countless children from a wide assortment of women, using in vitro fertilization to select gender as part of an amazingly creepy eugenics thing.

    Is that what we want? Is that what freedom looks like to you?

    It’s a hop skip and a jump from there to Brave New World style caste systems based on genetic lines being created in factories, and religions around Henry Ford, everyone being drugged on Soma, and banning Shakespeare and then introducing a noble savage plot that resolves in the noble savage killing himself because he’s in a terrible book and just can’t go on any longer. Also sexaphone concerts. And universal healthcare.

    Is that what you want?

    1
  33. Gustopher says:

    @charontwo:

    “Freedom is a fragile thing, and it’s never more than one generation away from extinction,” Ronald Reagan said in 1967, in his inaugural address as governor of California.

    So many people missed the point there, but the far right got it. It wasn’t a warning, it was encouragement. If you work hard, organize and pull yourself up by the bootstraps, you can destroy freedom in a single generation.

    3
  34. a country lawyer says:

    @becca: We’re about 30 miles west of Nashville and the wind is really building up. I expect the rain to hit within the hour and I can tell it’s going to be nasty

  35. Bill Jempty says:

    @a country lawyer:

    We’re about 30 miles west of Nashville and the wind is really building up. I expect the rain to hit within the hour and I can tell it’s going to be nasty

    It is about to rain cats and dogs. Just don’t step in a poodle.

    1
  36. Michael Reynolds says:

    Trump administration admits a Ukraine ceasefire ain’t happening. Trump gives away the farm, and Vlad still bitch-slaps him. Putin never wanted a peace deal, he still thinks he’s winning. This ceasefire was never anything but Trump babbling on the campaign trail, and the dumb fuck must have actually thought his master would give it to him.

    2
  37. just nutha says:

    @Gustopher: I really wish I didn’t see how your interpretation works.

    2
  38. Flat Earth Luddite says:

    @Gustopher:
    @just nutha:

    Even in our niave youth, we knew the revolution from the left didn’t have the legs to walk all the way to the finish line.

    OTOH , I didn’t seriously think the right could pull it off in my lifetime. Obviously, Cassandra the Seer I’m not.

    3
  39. Rob1 says:

    @Gustopher:

    When you start considering the alternatives to heterosexual, married, procreating couples you start getting things like billionaires having countless children from a wide assortment of women, using in vitro fertilization to select gender as part of an amazingly creepy eugenics thing.

    Is that what we want? Is that what freedom looks like to you?

    You forgot the “/s” right? Other wise, what total b.s.

    Elon is an aberration on an order of magnitude. We have many productive, non-gender typical people in non-typical relationships who contribute greatly to a civil, sustainable
    society.

    This kind of mania (if I’m hearing you correctly and I hope I’m not), that seeks to stamp out any deviation from straight collar, “Christian” conservative concepts of marriage by dragging us backwards in time to a repressed regulation of personal relationships (which have always taken place undercover anyway) is misguided political subterfuge, and thoroughly contrary to any pretense of “freedom.”

    A crazed, megalomaniacal narcissistic billionaire is gonna be doing meglomanical narcissistic crap regardless of what relationship norms we embrace or enforce. Elon’s “many loves” is the least of his bad behaviors in our society.

    The choice isn’t between accepting wider variance in personal relations or Elon’s eugenics-for-billionaires. That’s a false choice.

    And things get really weird when one considers that the straight-narrow conservative Christians are just fine with Elon’s ongoing destruction of “liberal” programs despite his decidedly amoral/immoral bent. Which just proves that this is really not about God, Jesus, or morality for the religious Right, but is solely about political expediency.

    Freedom and morality to me looks like “live and let live” as long as no one is oppressed, exploited, or abused, and the underaged are a protected status.

    1
  40. Jay L Gischer says:

    @Rob1: Pretty sure Gus was being ironic.

    2
  41. Jax says:

    Ugh…..my good friend, Cat Urbikigt, posted this today. She’s been a good friend and a mentor for a long time. One of the few “Sane Republicans” I know. We serve on one board together, and I’m not sure I want to be on the board anymore without her. They’re going to ask me to take over her job, and I don’t have the time. Or the knowledge. I only did it because they needed a cattle representative.

    https://caturbigkit.substack.com/p/the-bad-news?r=13nezy&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web&fbclid=IwY2xjawJaT3pleHRuA2FlbQIxMAABHVFlfrFaBaB1NyQtCWC_io-by4m3jDQ5teuROJCinv6iFzfMI7QBX0vN1w_aem_4ldEIkVahbKHUnN_K4lxUQ&triedRedirect=true

    1
  42. Mimai says:

    @Jax:
    I’m really sorry to hear about your friend. She sounds like an interesting and fierce woman.

    Take care of yourself and trust that you’ll do the next right thing.

    2
  43. Jax says:

    @Mimai: We have an OTB Cool Kids Signal Chat if you want to join. We were just talking about you, if you want to join. I am tiedyejax.74

    2
  44. Jax says:

    CSK, Becca (I need pics of Sadie!), Jen, Kathy, please join the Signal chat. I’d love to keep talking to you!