NYT (“Justice Alito Warns Court Overhaul Could Threaten Judicial Independence“):
Justice Samuel A. Alito Jr. on Monday warned against proposals to overhaul the Supreme Court by altering its composition, a move that he said would threaten the judiciary’s traditional independence.
His remarks came as Democrats, many of whom have advocated changes to the court, including expanding its membership or adopting term limits for the justices, prepare to take control of Congress in January.
Justice Alito did not detail any specific legislative proposal or refer to the change in political control on the horizon. However, speaking during a black-tie dinner in his honor hosted by the American Enterprise Institute, a right-leaning think tank, he pointedly critiqued the court’s critics, wading into the public debate over the justices’ rulings.
He described what he characterized as a mounting campaign in recent years by those opposed to the court’s rulings to change the direction of its decisions by intimidating and harassing justices.
“Or,” he said, “if that fails, by seriously damaging the court’s standing in the eyes of the public, and then altering the court’s composition,” he said.
Not long ago, I would have agreed with Alito. While nothing in the Constitution requires the Supreme Court to have nine members, it has been that size since the Judiciary Act of 1869 and, mostly, since 1837. Packing it to change its ideological composition absolutely undermines its independence; even Franklin Roosevelt couldn’t get a Democratic-controlled Congress to go along with it.
Alas, the Court has already been politicized, not least by Alito himself. He and Justice Clarence Thomas have become unapologetic shills for the Trump administration and Republican Party interests. Not to mention accepting substantial largesse from wealthy donors.
Further, the blocking of President Obama’s appointment of Merrick Garland, keeping the seat open for ten months so that a Republican could fill the seat instead, was a shameless partisan gambit. That it was followed by the rush appointment of Amy Coney Barrett less than two months before the 2020 election added insult to injury.
In light of all that, this is rather rich:
The court, Justice Alito said, could “soon face a structural question of greater magnitude: whether the court will be allowed to continue as an independent tribunal that decides cases based on its understanding of the law, not political pressure.”
Few believe the Court—and especially Alito—is doing that at this stage. Indeed:
Recent polls have shown declining public opinion of the Supreme Court, with a majority of Americans saying the justices are motivated mainly by politics rather than law, according to a September survey conducted by Marquette University Law School.
It’s almost certain that Democrats will maintain control of the Senate for at least the next four years, and the odds are significantly better than even that they’ll also take the White House after 2028. My preference would be that, rather than packing the Court in a way that would set off a cycle of tit-for-tat, they use that power to simply allow the appointment of two Justices per presidential term. This would regularize the process (Jimmy Carter got no appointments during his term, Bill Clinton got only two in eight years, George W. Bush got none in his first term, Barack Obama got only two in eight years, and Trump got three in his first term) and end the constant death watch and retirement pressure on sitting justices.








