AP (“Jussie Smollett released from county jail during appeal“):
Jussie Smollett was released from jail Wednesday following six nights behind bars after an appeals court agreed with his lawyers that he should be free pending the appeal of his conviction for lying to police about a racist and homophobic attack.
The former “Empire” actor walked out of the Cook County Jail surrounded by security. He did not comment as he got into an awaiting SUV, but his attorneys said Smollett, who is Black and gay, was the target of a racist justice system and people playing politics.
The appeals court ruling came after a Cook County judge sentenced Smollett last week to immediately begin serving 150 days in jail for his conviction on five felony counts of disorderly conduct for lying to police. In an outburst immediately after the sentence was handed down, Smollett proclaimed his innocence and said “I am not suicidal. And if anything happens to me when I go in there, I did not do it to myself. And you must all know that.”
The appeals court said Smollett could be released after posting a personal recognizance bond of $150,000, meaning he didn’t have to put down money but agrees to come to court as required.
So, the man has been convicted of five felonies. Absent evidence of jury tampering, an obviously biased judge, or the like, he’s presumed guilty. Why would he be freed? Much less out on his own recognizance given that he’s just been convicted of being a fraud? And, given his bizarre outbursts in court, is apparently mentally unstable.
Smollett defense attorney Nenye Uche, speaking to reporters outside the jail after Smollett left, said the Smollett family is “very very happy with today’s developments.” Uche said during his time at the jail, Smollett had not eaten and drank only water, though he did not say why.
He criticized the special prosecutor’s decision to charge Smollett again after the initial charges were dropped by Cook County State’s Attorney Kim Foxx and he paid a fine. He also called Judge James Linn’s sentence excessive for a low-level felony, adding that the appellate court doesn’t “play politics.”
“The real question is: Should Black men be walked into jail for a class 4 felony? Shame on you if you think they should,” Uche said.
He’s been convicted of five felonies. Which, by very definition, are punishable by no less than a year in prison. He’s been sentenced to 150 days and, in all likelihood, would only serve 75. And, frankly, it’s insulting for his attorney to play the race card given the nature of the crime.
The court’s decision marks the latest chapter in a strange story that began in January 2019 when Smollett reported to Chicago police that he was the victim of a racist and homophobic attack by two men wearing ski masks. The manhunt for the attackers soon turned into an investigation of Smollett himself and his arrest on charges that he’d orchestrated the attack and lied to police about it.
Authorities said Smollett paid two men he knew from work on the TV show “Empire” to stage the attack. Prosecutors said he told them what racist and homophobic slurs to shout, and to yell that Smollett was in “MAGA Country,” a reference to the campaign slogan of Donald Trump’s presidential campaign.
The claims were so farcically bizarre that Dave Chappelle did a four-minute bit lampooning Smollett:
Still, the story got national attention for days, wasted untold police manhours, and made a mockery of the whole system.
Special prosecutor Dan Webb recommended that Smollett serve “an appropriate amount of prison time” during sentencing.
“His conduct denigrated hate crimes,” Webb said after the hearing. “His conduct will discourage others who are victims of hate crimes from coming forward and reporting those crimes to law enforcement.”
This is balanced against, what, exactly?
Smollett’s attorneys had argued that he would have completed the sentence by the time the appeal process was completed and that Smollett could be in danger of physical harm if he remained locked up in Cook County Jail.
So, yes, because the sentence was very light, he would have served it before an appeal got heard. So? Having been convicted, he’s presumed guilty under the law. And, frankly, there’s simply zero question that he committed the crimes in question.
As to the dangers of being incarcerated, it’s a real concern. Except it was already being dealt with.
The office of the special prosecutor called the claim that Smollett’s health and safety were at risk “factually incorrect,” in a response to his motion, noting that Smollett was being held in protective custody at the jail.
Further, to the extent that jail is dangerous, that would be true for any convicted criminal. Or, indeed, even those charged with a crime who can’t afford bail. Should we just let them all go home?
As a general matter, I think we over-incarcerate. It’s arguable that alternative sentencing is more appropriate for non-violent offenders like Smollett. Still, 75 days under protective custody in the county jail isn’t exactly life in Shawshank.
