Sunday’s Forum
Steven L. Taylor
·
Sunday, October 13, 2024
·
37 comments
OTB relies on its readers to support it. Please consider helping by becoming a monthly contributor through Patreon or making a one-time contribution via PayPal. Thanks for your consideration.
About Steven L. Taylor
Steven L. Taylor is a Professor Emeritus of Political Science and former College of Arts and Sciences Dean. His main areas of expertise include parties, elections, and the institutional design of democracies. His most recent book is the co-authored
A Different Democracy: American Government in a 31-Country Perspective. He earned his Ph.D. from the University of Texas and his BA from the University of California, Irvine. He has been blogging since 2003 (originally at the now defunct Poliblog).
Follow Steven on
Twitter and/or
BlueSky.
Some more NAR stuff, at the Mall in DC.
“NBC”
JD Vance, Mike Johnson, Project 2025 are all very into this stuff.
This is why the Trump campaign is airing all those anti-trans ads at football games, etc. Typical fascist demonization of minorities.
Jokes for a post Project 2025 America:
At the maximum security prison for dangerous enemies of the people, the warden picks three inmates at random and asks them whet they’re in for.
The first one says, “I spoke out against JD Vance.”
“I see,” says the warden. he turns to the second and asks, “how about you?”
“I spoke out in favor of JD Vance,” the second one says.
“You sure did.” The warden turns to the third. “And what brought you here?”
The third prisoner says “I am JD Vance.”
Abortion emerges as most important election issue for young women, poll finds (ABC)
More lyrics free opera, The Marriage of Figaro overture by Mozart.
Apologies for the length, this is part of a much longer piece on Steve Bannon, J D Vance, NATO, Ukraine, Brexit etc,, it’s all pretty scary IMO:
“VanityFair”
snip
There is a lot more.
@charontwo:
I think fear and moral panic are Trump’s secret special sauce. He calls himself the “Protector.” the macho tough guy, the strong man (right out of Ben Garrison cartoons or McNaughton paintings).
The suckers are afraid of change, modernity, lack of religion and they gobble this swill right up.
I think the Democrats need to attack this, make him look weak, incoherent etc.
https://open.substack.com/pub/margaretsullivan/p/about-those-new-york-times-headlines?utm_source=share&utm_medium=android&r=9qjyo
@DeD:
So the NYT flunks Journalism 101, not a new observation, and getting no respect in its quest for interviews. And not open to learning.
This goes way back, Whitewater, Judith Miller, Buttery Males etc.etc.
@charontwo:
More from the Vanity Fair linky:
There are a lot of these people, they are well connected and dead serious.
So the key issue for the Trump campaign is anti-immugrant. That is almost their own focus, and it seems to be working. The immigrants are stealing your job, your housing costs too much because of them, all crime us from immigrants and FEMA is out of money because they spent it on immigrants. I would not be surprised if the origin of the Haitian s eating pets is the campaign itself. If Trump wins, I give him two years at the most and then they push him out, and Vance will be in. Then the billionaires and competent crazies will be running things.
This is such a good piece (Vanity Fair quoted above), I feel guilty and tedious about excerpting such long quotes, but it’s paywalled so …
“Vanity Fair”
@charontwo: So, a guy who runs a paramilitary, mercenary company thinks the US spends too much on its military.
Why hire and train people, where you can just pay Eric Prince when you need troops? Troops that won’t be troubled by niceties like oaths to the Constitution and so on.
Weimar levels of debt? Only in your motivated-reasoning, cherry-picked dreams.
Also, where were you when Rs proposed tax cuts that made the debt worse? Cheering them on?
Who knows what Vance really cares about, if anything besides his own ambition and power.
He will team with anyone Thiel, Wallnau, Trump, Musk anyone he can use to get some more.
Fascinating that the only solution is entitlement cuts and not tax increases on the highest earners.
Guys like Bannon and Vance are the most obvious signs of decline. They’re like a barbarian who took the Marcus Lucius Augustus in 410 after looting a library, and the idea we need to upend our entitlement program in order to finance defense spending for a war that is not on the horizon or really even imaginable is an end of the empire MLM scheme.
@charontwo:
Non-paywalled version.
@DK:
I don’t even think it’s just abortion specifically. Abortion is like a stand in for the entire array of “abusing women” positions that the Republican party supports
An upstanding young male Trump fan says he won’t vote for Harris because she’s an abortion-loving whore:
http://www.rawstory.com/trump-supporter-christian/
Talk about incels.
@Joe: Not as much as you might think. Not paying taxes is foundational to the beginnings of the nation.
@Joe: “restructure how we pay for benefits like Medicare and Social Security” could include raising taxes.
It probably doesn’t, but it could.
It could also include creating a special task force to rob citizens at gunpoint. Highway Robbery as a funding mechanism. Perhaps in other countries.
I’ve been thinking about the 3/5ths compromise lately, as one does, and how the 13th Amendment bans slavery and involuntary servitude except for people convicted of a crime.
Many states effectively require prisoners to work while in prison. For House districts, shouldn’t those prisoners only count as 3/5ths of a person?
This sent me down a shallow rabbit hole to Section 2 of the 14th Amendment:
That takes away the 3/5ths compromise, but arguably adds a new wrinkle — if the right to vote is denied or abridged in any way, the states representation shall be reduced in proportion.
Before I wander further down this rabbit hole — as it is a lovely day outside and the litter box needs cleaning and I should either spend the day outside or scrubbing a litter box — shouldn’t this mean that a state’s number of representatives be directly affected by voter suppression?
Also, it would seem to very explicitly penalize any state where the legislature were to appoint electors — which might come up in the next election, as Trump and his cronies wanted it to come up in 2020. Granted, I don’t think the American Republic of Trumpistan would feel particularly obliged to live up to the US Constitution.
I really do not want to clean that litter box.
@Gustopher: What you’re describing is directly relevant to a chapter from a book I read recently, which I highly recommend: One Person, One Vote: A Surprising History of Gerrymandering in America, by Nick Seabrook.
It delves heavily into the topic of gerrymandering from its inception (tracing its roots to a phenomenon in the Middle Ages known as rotten boroughs) to the present day. But it also discusses phenomena that may not fit the technical definition of gerrymandering but which are closely related, and one of those is prison gerrymandering.
That’s literally what it’s called–there’s a group called the Prison Gerrymandering Project, aimed at fighting this problem. What it refers to is the fact that prisons tend to be located outside of the areas in which the prisoners lived when they were free citizens, and often that means people from more urban areas being relocated to rural areas. They get counted in the census as residents of the areas where the prisons are located, despite having little to no contact with the surrounding communities and (apart from a couple of states) being unable to vote. As a result, the districts containing these prisons get disproportionate representation. So it’s basically a version of the 3/5ths situation all over again, a fact underscored by the prisoners being disproportionately minorities, lending undue representation to white rural areas.
And that’s not even getting into the way forced labor at prisons constitutes a loophole (laid out explicitly in the 13th Amendment) to the ban on involuntary servitude.
Question of the day: what are the NATO Article V implications of Israel launching a chemical weapons attack on Italian peacekeeping troops in Southern Lebanon?
UN says Israeli tanks burst into base, Israel gives different account
DNA testing reveals that Columbus was a Jew from Spain; he concealed his Jewishness to avoid persecution.
@charontwo: @Mimai: Thanks for the link. That Vanity Fair article is scary stuff. It sure reads like Bannon wants to burn everything down with nothing to replace it. Maybe just revert to competing nation states. That worked so well up through 1945.
@CSK:
This has been debated for years, though up to now there’s been no conclusive DNA evidence to support the hypothesis and there was a general consensus that it was doubtful. I’m a little skeptical of this new study (which is revealed in a documentary), but we’ll see if it holds up.
Claims that modern DNA studies prove this or that historical figure to have been secretly of Jewish origin, from Thomas Jefferson to Adolf Hitler, often turn out to be a lot less than meets the eye.
@Gustopher:
A provision of the Constitution historically more honored in the breach than the observance. In fact, entirely in the breach, despite numerous opportunities for observance.
https://x.com/OurShallowState/status/1845515857541349466
@Kylopod:
Ignores the possibility his ancestors converted to Catholicism at some point too, as a significant number of European Jews did, and he might not have even known.
Apparently a guy named Vern Miller, 49, a self-proclaimed sovereign citizen was arrested a mile a way from Trump’s Coachella rally carrying a fake press pass, a fake VIP pass, a handgun, and a shotgun with a high capacity magazine. He was later released on $5000 bond.
@dazedandconfused:
It’s possible, but most of the conversos were converted under duress and maintained their Jewish identity in secret. Columbus set sail just a few days after the edict of expulsion, and he had conversos on his ship with him. If he was of Jewish descent, while we may not be able to know for sure, it’s likely he knew about it and was keeping it secret to avoid persecution at a time when conversos were a prime target.
@charontwo:
And, the historically low garbage president that he was, somehow, even though he hated the central banking system, he ends up on the $20 bill.
You can’t make this stuff up.
@CSK:
You know, there’s some irony in that the party calling for violence is the one on the receiving end of so many assassination attempts.
@Kathy:
Or, at least, it gives a bit of insight into what they really meant by “law and order” for all of those years…
On other Weirdo Felon rally news, attendees were stranded at the venue when not enough buses showed up to shuttle them back to the parking area, over 3 km away (about a 2 hour walk).
the same thing happened in Omaha four years ago. That time under very harsh winter conditions.
The obvious explanation is El Weirdo cares that the audience shows up, but not about how they get back home. The cult members, though, are inventing conspiracy theories on the spot. This is how they can keep believing the leopards won’t eat their face, as they are eating their face.
Video commentary on same.
@CSK: One guy gets to shoot his mouth off and lo and behold he’s in national media. It’s a trend story!!! It’s a breathless take!!! It’s based on polls that also have tiny samples, and may be horse shit.
Yeah, there’s always some guy with a crazy opinon.