Outside the Beltway

An Argument Against Bombing Syria…

Steven L. Taylor
10

Comments

…can be found simply by looking at who supports the action.  Scott Lemieux at LGM notes:  “Experts” Who Are Always Wrong About Everything Want to Bomb Syria.

Said experts include:  Joe Lieberman, Bernard-Henri Levy, Karl Rove, Bill Kristol, Elliott Abrams, Leon Wieseltier as well as “Max Boot, Paul Berman, Dr. Clifford D. May, Marty Peretz, and Danielle Pletka.”

I can’t speak for every name on the list, but many of the more prominent ones no only have been wrong an awful lot, but also appear impervious to learning from past mistakes.

(Yes, I am being a bit snarky here, but sometimes snark illuminates the path of truth).

Categories

,

Tags

, , , ,

10 responses to “An Argument Against Bombing Syria…”

  1. legion Avatar
    legion

    I was all ready to support you 100% on this one, Prof, and then I went and looked one thing up – John Bolton thinks military action in Syria is likely to cause more problems than doing nothing. Now I’m confused… people whose opinions I consider bellwethers of “what to do the opposite of” are disagreeing…

  2. Steven L. Taylor Avatar
    Steven L. Taylor

    @legion: Oh, my. That does create something of a conundrum.

  3. Rob in CT Avatar
    Rob in CT

    So we have Obama lining up with a fools gallery, and me agreeing with John Bolton. It might be funny if we weren’t talking about life and death.

  4. Ron Beasley Avatar
    Ron Beasley

    @legion: Bolton probably fears that getting involved in Syria would end up interfering with an attack on Iran.

  5. Donald Sensing Avatar
    Donald Sensing

    Those of us who want to stop this madness should try to get George W. Bush to endorse it. Then maybe Obama will reconsider. Maybe.

    I wish I had more time to write in detail about the strategic folly of the apparently-upcoming strikes. But then, I covered a lot of that ground in the buildup to the Libya bombing in March 2011. Someone had asked me whether Obama had a Plan B for Libya, to which I replied, “Plan B? There isn’t even a Plan A!”

    Much of that post applies today re. Syria. “Hope is not a method, and wishes are not plans.”

  6. timb Avatar
    timb

    @legion: Man, that is a huge problem! Neither Bloody Bill Kristol nor Bolton have EVER been right about anything and yet that disagree? Is this like the time Spock told that robot he could not lie and then stated he was lying? And, like, the robot blew up?

    Come to think of it, the ideal situation here would be for Bolton and Kristol to blow up

  7. Tillman Avatar
    Tillman

    @legion @Steven L. Taylor: Maybe, and I’m winging it a bit on this, we should come up with some sort of “Bonehead” Calculus to weigh always-wrong pundits (expressed in kilomorrises) on either side of an issue to divine the most probabilistic course being actually wrong.

  8. Jon Hendry Avatar
    Jon Hendry

    “Dr. Clifford D. May”

    I assume this must be a diploma mill doctorate, because Cliff’s bio on his site only mentions two Master’s degrees.

  9. legion Avatar
    legion

    @Tillman: I like that. It plays in with the use of a Friedman as a unit of time…

  10. Jenos Idanian #13 Avatar
    Jenos Idanian #13

    Here’s another fun factoid: in 2007, Joe Biden said that if then-president Bush bombed Iran without Congressional approval, then he would push for Bush’s impeachment.

    Of course, at that point Joe Biden was a Senator, and it’s the House that impeaches, but at least Slow Joe’s heart was in the right place…

    Thanks to Ace of Spades for that blast from the past…

Latest Posts