OTB relies on its readers to support it. Please consider helping by becoming a monthly contributor through Patreon or making a one-time contribution via PayPal. Thanks for your consideration.

Comments
OTB relies on its readers to support it. Please consider helping by becoming a monthly contributor through Patreon or making a one-time contribution via PayPal. Thanks for your consideration.
Categories
Tags
More and more when I see what AI is being touted for, it is about making choices for you. For instance, Google is putting AI into its Maps app:
Use Ask Maps to plan a day trip for holiday shopping or something more complex — like a three-day road trip with stops for coastal hikes and oceanfront dining. You’ll get a day-by-day schedule with insider tips and numbered map pins for each stop, making it easy to visualize the plan. Once you’re happy with the itinerary, share it with friends and family, or export it to Google Docs on desktop.
Serious question: Who wants this? I don’t mean, “Why would anyone want this?!”, but am just curious as to the type of person who would say, “I want to go on a trip, but I want some(thing) else to do all the planning, booking, etc and I’ll just go along with what it has chosen”? Is this the way the uber-wealthy live? Like, they have an assistant and they say “Assistant, I have 36 hours before the board meeting in NYC and I desire amusement. Plan me a trip that begins here and ends in NYC and includes ocean side dining and a Pro basketball game.”
FWIW, for four years I had an assistant who would have done that for me if I had asked, but it never even occurred to me to have her book personal travel based on my likes and dislikes. Once you start planning a trip everything becomes so conditional. For example, earlier this year I was on a business trip to England and it was cheaper if I flew in a day earlier and paid an extra night for a hotel, so I ended up with a day in London. I must’ve spent 4 or more hours looking up who was playing at which Jazz venues, what brew pubs were nearby, and then finding a hotel that was within walking distance of all that. Planning and trading things off was half the fun of the trip!
I can see some value in having an app assist in planning a trip when you know what you want to see and when. Or if you’re short on time and are visiting an unfamiliar place you know nothing about.
Then again, package tours have been around for decades, with preplanned itineraries you pay for. On my first trip to Vegas I took a day tour like that of Hoover Dam. There was plenty of time at the dam, I set one foot in Arizona, the bus driver/tour guide was witty, informative, and pleasant. On the other hand, I would have chosen just about anything other than the buffet at Sam’s Town for lunch. And the highlight of the stop at Ethel M’s chocolate factory was the garden of desert plants outside.
An AI is never going to know what I want because I don’t know what I want until I see it. We are going to Paris in June as a delayed b’day present for my wife: there’s a particular performance of the B minor mass she wants to attend. (I may not have any class, but I married class.)
The week before or after are up to me to pick. So far I’ve considered London, Botswana, Morocco, Krakow, Budapest and Vietnam. Tell me, AI: what should I do?And that’s before get into the hotel. Will I trade a smaller room for a balcony? Is that lobby cool or gloomy? How about the restaurant possibilities? How to weigh a great bathroom against no room service?
What is really sad is that my eldest who has gone back to college has a minor in math because she loves math. She just texted me a long depressed note about Anthropic solving the Riemann hypothesis. So an AI can do that crossword puzzle for you in a millisecond. Great, and now there’s no fucking point in crossword puzzles.
Well, I think there are a lot of “find the possibilities” web searching that is not work that many people enjoy.
What are all the shows available in London for the following three-day weekend? Is a question you might ask. I expect that there isn’t a one-stop website for this.
(Newspapers used to do this, but if you are on another continent, that doesn’t work, and nowadays, newspapers maybe don’t do this as a service.)
So, you have some other activities, and maybe there’s stuff you don’t know about. So folks used to go to a travel agent for stuff like that, why not go to an AI?
I mean, it’s sold as a one-and-done, but maybe that doesn’t have to be the way it works?
It’s mildly useful for stuff like that, but whenever I ask them “what are all the X that meet the following criteria?” types of questions, if it is something I know a lot about already I see that they usually miss some key answers, and include some that, upon further research, don’t meet the criteria. So I assume that is happening if I ask it about things I don’t know very much about.
Well, I do that, but the planner is my husband. 😀
Seriously, he has strong opinions about what he likes to do and what he wants to see. I’m more laid-back, and for the most part am fine with what he plans. In fact, I hate being asked a zillion questions about stuff! We are not uber-wealthy, I’m just not particular about some things! He knows what my bright lines are, and incorporates those into planning.
ETA: I would not hand that off to AI though. I’ve read too many stories about things going awry when people offload their thinking to a computer.
Would love to hear more about your camping experiences. My wife and I have a small camper trailer, and will retire next year, so starting in 2028 we hit the road and expect to be more or less continuously on it for 1-3 years depending on how things work out. We are definitely the serendipitous types, too
reach out to me at jfm_stl@yahoo.com. No need to clutter the thread.
I frequently see folks posting their AI generated agendas on an Iceland travel group (plus the same questions over and over – Has anyone ever been to X? Nope, you are the 1st guest, ha). However a great AI-related post was where the person asked AI to “roast” their schedule and it pointed out it was extremely busy and that the trip was mostly driving and it concluded “but it will all work out,” which I saw as a play on the Icelandic phrase Þetta reddast.
lol, you and Chancellor Merz seem to sharing head-space:
Mr Merz said Mr Trump’s meeting with Mr Putin and China’s President Xi Jinping in Shenzhen “first and foremost was a photo op”.
Also Merz:
“President Trump can rely on this teamwork as long as we pursue the same goal.”
Which is diplomatically implying the obvious corollary: “and if not, not, and then be damned to you.”
Some “significant efforts” toward peace in Ukraine.
Trump called on European leaders to stop supporting Ukraine.
While Russian missiles and drones hit Poland near where NATO exercises are taking place.
And not a peep about it from the US.
Message received and understood.
All AI is for me is an enhanced search engine. Google realizes this. Rather than Google my question as in the past, just type it into Gemini to then quickly search myriad of sites and provide a response. Google knows this and is capitalizing on it as they know it’s killing the search engine model. Anything else I have used it for results in a “meh, not really what I need or am looking for or to do” reaction. Hence why I don’t see how it creates a revenue stream to outweigh it’s massive costs. Maybe in Science and Tech, but everyday folks and everyday things, not so much. Sure as heck ain’t paying for it. Here in NVA see so many data centers built. Many empty. Waiting for what? Power and energy of course, but what else? Promised demand? Its weird
Oh, it’s a lot more than that.
Generating responses to structured requests if it has the underlying rule-set is a useful thing.
Assuming the request is properly formulated, and the rule-set comprehensively assimilated.
That’s why it works well with coding, where there is a logical structure and massive online documentation and analysis, and is generally quite accurate, based on explication without reason for falsehood.
Generally.
But GIGO: it can easily fall over where the internet-scraped data is a consensus of bollocks.
For companies, it can use internal rule-sets and data and iterative correction to enable automated data-processing to replace a lot of previously human decisions about pricing, logistics optimisation, etc etc.
And to search massive data-sets for relevant information.
All very useful.
But …
The basic problem of the AI build-out is that it’s assuming a revenue stream that appears impossible to achieve.
Even if it displaced 10% of US labour costs, that would be about $1.5 trillion.
Projections of required income to fund current projected capex by c 2030 are about $2 trillion.
And current estimates are not showing a profit gain for non-tech business of anything like near enough to pay for it.
In short: where the hell is the sodding money supposed to be coming from?
Never mind the obvs time-lag issues.
And that is what a lot of people are starting to calculate.
It’s the dotcoms or the railways all over again.
And at least the tulips actually grew.
Part of the issue seems to have been that so many pieces of internet-related code are based on geological dog-years of voluntary effort, with no consistent security testing, and all “somebody else’s problem”.
And hooking in to them, all the various site systems that themselves are often kludged, and use common scripts and components of similar lack of verification.
The entire thing is a bit of a mess.
Trump has reacted to the prospect of US companies operating AI data-centres offshore by threatening a “tremendous tax”.
On what legal basis seems unclear, given the need for Congress to actually enact taxes.
Or perhaps the Supreme Court might grant him such powers?
Who can tell?
This will doubtless come as nasty surprise to the Saudis and Emiratis, who have been projecting solar-powered data-centres as a major new line of development.
Bribery incoming?
His reasoning being that “China will take all of them”
And citing in particular the Finnish data centre project.
“They want to build that one in Finland, and we’re not allowing that to happen.”
China is about to “take” Finland?
Who knew?
The man is really losing it.
Meanwhile, Anthropic stock is back down to about it’s issue price, in a global tech-stock rout, that’s tanking markets generally.
Many people, I suspect, are currently trying to locate their shirts, and being disappointed by their absence.
The markets next week are going to be interesting.
Perhaps for an “interesting times” value of such.
Once again re Ukraine:
At APEC Australian PM Albanese pointedly departs from the Trumpian narrative:
“And I say very directly to President Putin: end your war, end it now.”
At the European summit in Brussels, Chancellor Merz:
PM Burnham:
“It’s not for the aggressor in this conflict to set out wide ranging and unrealistic security demands. … And I hope that message is heard very clearly, in Moscow: for as long as it takes. We will be there at the side of Ukraine, and we will not falter. Our support will be unwavering.”
President Macron:
“Everyone who is here today have to do everything in their power so that Ukraine has everything it needs in order to resist and to defend herself …”
It should be noted that Kushner and Witkoff were in the room when these statements were made.
The message is plain enough: Trump can shove his attempts to pander to Putin.
Kushner made some statements on progress in negotiations. Many of which have already been contradicted by Russia, and the rest add up to vague words.
Europe generally seems now to view words from either Washington or Moscow as of little value.
What matters is money, and power, and actual binding agreements.
You must be logged in to post a comment.