Recognizing that the whole Tale of the Two Dans is getting disproportionate attention, I can’t help but continue to keep thinking about it because it intersects a number of topics I write about, including: the weakness of US parties, the need for electoral reform, the role of partisanship in our elections, the poorly representative nature of our institutions, and the current threats to US democracy.
So, here we go.
Weak Parties. Again, let’s look at the ballot line:

Note the party affiliation by the Dans Sullivan and note the following hi-larious stand-up bit:
PoliSci Comedian (to the audience): These parties so weak!
PoliSci Comedian: These parties so weak that they can’t control their own label as part of a dumb duplicate Dan Sullivan ballot stacking op!
Audience (in unison): How weak are they?
I mean, the jokes write themselves!
What could be a better illustration of the lack of label control by our major parties than this? Not only was it possible to get a second Dan Sullivan on the ballot, but he gets to use the Republican label.
This is the chef’s kiss of weak parties.‘
Update: Never mind, I am an idiot who conflated the Dan J. with Heikes. The point still kind of stands for Heikes, but barely.
Bad Reform/Barely Reform. As was noted in a comment on one of the Alaska posts, I am an advocate for electoral reform. Well, some might say, Alaska engaged in reform, so what’s the problem? Take what you can get, Taylor!
The problem is that this is barely a reform, given that the core problem is single-seat districts, not the decision rule that determines the winner. Alaska’s Top Four is just a fancy way of trying to produce an absolute majority winner (although there are scenarios in which it potentially still might not). In its effect on the behavior of parties, politicians, and voters, it is not all that different from Georgia’s requirement for a 50%+1 winner for Congress, and therefore the possibility of a second round, if needed.
As far as it goes, I have no specific objection to absolute majority requirements, but they do not create the kinds of incentives needed for politicians to form new parties, nor for voters to be willing to cast their ballots for new parties.
The core incentive remains primarily focused on the two main party labels, especially when the rules allow more than one candidate to use the same party label (as with our two Dans).*
The reality is that systems like Top Two (CA and WA–which has some significant differences, but the general process is not that different) and Top Four in Alaska are not producing new parties, but instead encourage more people to use Rs and Ds.
To me, this is all what political scientist Jack Santucci would call “anti-party” reforms. They shift the incentive structure away from parties and place even more emphasis on individual candidates. I mean, what do party labels even mean if contests have multiple Rs or Ds on the ballot?
Partisanship. I am going to make an observation that may get me in trouble with some readers, but I feel compelled to do so. Further, and before I make the observation, I will state, unequivocally, that I am not making a “both sides” argument in terms of the severity of the dirty trick in question. GOP leadership fomented an insurrection on January 6, 2021, in an attempt to retain power. The current leadership is trying any number of ways to deny citizens the vote. A stupid bit of duplicate Dan ratfuckery is harmless by comparison.
Nonetheless, if anyone found themselves predisposed to immediately defend the action, it may be because of one’s partisan preferences. And, further, it is highly likely that if a Republican had done the same in a Senate race that one was hoping would flip to D, one would have been a lot less forgiving.
This is a minor example of the kind of partisan influence over political choices that I constantly note. We react to things like this (as with candidates) through partisan filters.
(To me, this is more an observation for contemplation, but feel free to tell me I am full if in the comments.)
Stupid Institutions. The whole thing is a national story because we are all concerned about who will control the US Senate. We all have to worry that the population of the 48th most populous state (with just over 500,000 registered voters, of whom maybe a little over half will vote) will determine, possibly, whether Trump gets a fourth pick for SCOTUS, for example. This is a weird way to run a continental democracy of over 340 million people.
The 10+ million voters in Texas, to pick the other extreme, have the same say in such matters as, say, 300,000-ish voters in Alaska. So, maybe just maybe Dan confusion or backlash against Peltola could determine a SCOTUS seat or other judgeships. Cool!
The institutional structure helps fuel our interest and anxieties surrounding this contest.
(For the record, I don’t think all of this will matter, but the fact that we have to even think about it, or why we are so invested, is a direct result of constitutional design.)
The Anti-Democracy of It All. Again, as noted above, this is almost certainly legal (I hedge only because I am not an expert in AK election law, nor do I have perfect knowledge of all that happened to get us where we are) and yes, yes (a thousand times yes!), the GOP has done far worse things to our democracy. But I stand by my assessment that anyone who is part of the pro-democracy coalition needs to avoid giving fuel to the arsonists who want to burn democracy down.
I understand that Trump is going to say that the election was rigged and stolen no matter what the Dems do, but I just find giving him any kind of concrete example of Democratic chicanery around the electoral process to be shooting the pro-democracy side in the foot. It helps create additional space in the motivated-reasoning permission structure where a lot of GOP voters are currently swimming.
I don’t think it is pearl-clutching to make that assessment.
This reminds me of the assertion that “all politicians are liars.” This is an old trope that has been a persistent feature in American politics as long as there has been politics. I remember talking about this in class, and trying to get students to see the difference between straight-up lying and failure to follow-through on campaign promises or the difference between spinning and lying.
I am not going to say that politicians, as a class, are paragons of radical candor, but the reality is that they blatantly lie far less than the general perception would suggest.
But that perception, that politicians lie, has given Trump a radical permission structure. And it also makes it harder for Democrats to be seen as untruthful, because any time the Dems can be seen as lying, it makes it easier for Republican voters to dismiss Trump’s torrent of untruth.
Hear me, please: I am not saying that, to pick a prominent example, Obama saying, “if you like your health care plan, you can keep it” (given the “Lie of the Year” award) justifies Trump’s torrent of blatant lies with no connection to reality. Hell, I still don’t think that Obama’s “lie” was a lie as much as a combination of being mistaken/spinning the situation (as most people did, in fact, keep their health care plans). But do not discount the degree to which anti-Obama Republicans can take such things and use them to rationalize their support for Trump.
Never forget the power of the human mind to rationalize.
(The same is true about “all politicians are corrupt” as a rationalization for a lot of people to ignore Trump’s blatant corruption.)
And I maintain that this is just a stupid trick to begin with, and has backfired to a degree because it has become this national story, taking energy away from other stories as a result.
By the way, yes, it is unfair and asymmetrical that something like this receives the attention that it does, which, to me, is again an illustration of what an own goal it is.
For a counterpoint on this part of my post, I gladly give you Josh Marshall: Let’s Talk About Alaska.
I’ve heard a number of people say they’re “troubled” or “disturbed” or unhappy that this happened. All I can say is that I would really recommend that you toughen up because you simply won’t make it through the next few years, even under the best circumstances.
My response to that is: I am ready for hardball. I am ready for a fight for democracy.
But, for crying out loud, could we do things that are smart, effective, and promote democracy, rather than stupid stunts that give fuel to arsonists?
Ok, enough about all of this until we get the results.
*”Our Two Dans” is a new sitcom coming this fall to CBS!









