While I have not returned to my ongoing project of connecting the politics of fascism to contemporary Republican politics of late, Marco Rubio provided an example in a recent speech to the Federalist Society.
I would note two side notes before getting to my main point, which are as follows. First, it is a weird choice to address an association of lawyers by telling them the sword is mightier than the law. Second, watch his face; he clearly thought he was about to get a huge response from the audience as he was about to read the line, before he had to pivot to a “please clap” moment.
It seems worth noting as well that the Bro of War thought it was a totally rad thing to say.

The main point is this: such rhetoric is utterly illiberal and is plainly fascist.
I am old enough to remember when one of the pillars of the US government was “rule of law.” Further back in my day, a clear component of liberal democracy was subordination of the military (men with swords) to civilian control (the law). Yes, I know he was talking about international law, but that does not absolve him of the problems I am here identifying. Even if one wishes to debate the logic of the ICC or whatnot, the notion that might makes right should have no place in our discourse, especially from a Secretary of State (not to mention National Security Adviser plus Chief Cook and Bottle Washer) who clearly wants to be president. It seems worth adding that a lot of international law is linked to treaties ratified by Congress, which constitutionally makes them domestic law as well.
A thoughtful person could debate and address aspects of the international system that they found objectionable. A brute pulls out the sword and threatens violence.
I would refer the reader back to my post on Umberto Eco’s essay on fascism, and to specifically note the following components of his definition, which are relevant to assessing Rubio’s cute little quote:
#3. Values action over reason.
#9. Life is permanent warfare.
#11. Machismo
I would also note this quote from Mussolini, which I noted in a previous post:
“Fascism … discards pacifism as a cloak for cowardly supine renunciation in contradistinction to self-sacrifice. War alone keys up all human energies to their maximum tension and sets the seal of nobility on those peoples who have the courage to face it.”
On one level, it is easy to want to dismiss all of this as a too-clever-by-half college sophomore thinking he just hit it out of the park at his first CEDA (Cross-Examination Debate Association) tournament. But on the other, the man is the Secretary of State, and he wants to be the President of the United States.
There are three basic options, and none are good.
- Rubio always thought this way, and any evidence that he was a “normie” Republican was a lie.
- Rubio changed his mind and now thinks this way.
- He thinks that this is what the contemporary GOP wants, so he is willing to say it (which dovetails with #1, as it suggests he is just a power-seeking chameleon).
Anyone who thinks that this man is the one to lead the GOP out of the wilderness is wrong. This should have been obvious from the moment he decided, like so many power-craving cowards, to bend the knee to Trump. His willingness to sell his dignity for power is there for us all to see.
But, to me, Rubio isn’t the main story here; rather, all of this is just a further bit of evidence of the fascist and illiberal pathway the GOP appears willing to tread into the future.








