Photo by SLT (All Rights Reserved)

Stupid Election Tricks

Adding to, not duplicating, the contents of the previous post.

22

Comments

As sometimes happens, James beat me to the punch (I was writing a post about the Dans Sullivan when I saw he posted one). Let me cut to the chase, leaving James’ post to provide the context: this was a dumb plan and a waste of time with significant negative consequences beyond the Senate race itself.

As I stated in my post on the Trump administration’s lawsuit on this same subject: it makes my brain hurt to figure out under what kind of convoluted scenario having a spoiler on an RCV ballot would be advantageous.

I think a lot of this is that people have First Past the Post Brain and can’t conceive of how electoral rules change the parameters of a contest.

Sure, if in an FPTP election you had a scenario in which Peltola had 49.5% of the vote, Dan S. had 49.4% of the vote, and a handful of voters got confused and voted for Dan J., then the dirty trick pays off.

But since voters can rank their choices, including voting for both Dans, how does any of this help?

I would note that Alaska is a state that managed to successfully elect Lisa Murkowski via a write-in campaign. This suggests an electorate that can distinguish between two Dan Sullivans/read and understand the word “incumbent” on the ballot, because, contrary to what certain people say, most folks know what the word means (or can figure it out from context clues). It even has a “b” in it!

I don’t think that this cunning plan will ultimately matter to the outcome.

However, in addition to being underhanded, it was foolish and counterproductive.

It helps contribute to the general sense that all politicians are corrupt, which gives cover to Trump’s far more significant and far more insidious corruption. This will aid partisans and their motivated reasoning concerning Trump, and it is a far easier-to-understand story for low-information voters than things like how Trump made a ton of money on crypto or how Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff are subverting national security to line their pockets.

Further, it aids Trump strategy of creating deep distrust of American democracy.

So great job, Peltola! You have sullied your name in a scheme that is of little use and have helped chip away a bit more at the reputation of American electoral democracy.

22 responses to “Stupid Election Tricks”

  1. It is not great that the Peltola campaign ginned this up though it is a pretty common tactic.

    The Dan Sullivans Affair is underhanded, of course, but this has happened a number of times before. Just 4 years ago Republicans found a guy named Mike Doyle to run for the seat of retiring Democratic Rep. Mike Doyle: http://www.yahoo.com/news/2-polit…— Paul Waldman (@paulwaldman.bsky.social) 2026-10-29T12:52:57.596Z

    https://embed.bsky.app/static/embed.js

    But, as Dr. Taylor notes, it seems like in a ranked vote state it really should have very, very minimal effect, if any. I mean, if you want Dan Sullivan-R incumbent, just rank all Dan Sullivans as the non incumbent will drop out of the count quickly.

    2
  2. For the first time in history Democrats didn’t bring a marshmallow to a knife fight, they ACTUALLY brought a knife.
    Meanwhile Trump has weaponized the entire f’ing govt against them.
    Stop clutching them pearls.

    1. @Daryl Except, no, they didn’t. They barely brought a marshmallow. This was utterly stupid. It isn’t fighting, and it accomplished nothing.

      4
      1. Well what it accomplished, if it had gone undetected, is unknowable.
        I mean, there is a reason it happens repeatedly.
        But at the very least they TRIED.

      2. We can get philosophical and ask whether a knife-shaped marshmallow qualifies as knife.

  3. Dr. Taylor: “Voters need more choices and ranked choice voting in order to lessen partisanship”

    Alaska candidates, legislature,and supreme court: “Done”

    Dr. Taylor: “Not like that”

    1
    1. @thommol5487

      “Voters need more choices and ranked choice voting in order to lessen partisanship”

      BTW, I have never in my life said that quote. To the degree that I would support RCV, it would be in multi-seat districts. I have been consistently opposed to RCV in single-seat districts.

      I am not even asking to lessen partisanship, per se, but want to have a system with more than two partisan choices.

      It is true that I am not a fan of single-seat RCV, although this post isn’t about that.

      But since what I want, in fact, is a system that promotes new party development and real competition, could you show how this race is producing that?

      We have on this ballot basically an R and D and two very minor competitors in a race that is clearly between the R and the D.

      There isn’t even a new party label on this ballot (there are two Rs, a D, and an independent).

  4. @Steven: You’re right, of course, assuming all voters rank all four candidates. But what of those who accidentally vote for the fake Dan Sullivan and don’t vote for a second choice? In a close election, that could be decisive.

    1. The party and incumbency Is clearly shown. At some point voters have to have some agency, no.matter.whay this blog has been pushing since the rise of Trump.

      5
      1. Don’t you know we voters are just potted plants within a system?

        3
    2. The odds of this are pretty small given the design of the ballot and the -R and incumbent on the line.

      Seems much less likely and even less chance of it being material compared to the 2000 butterfly ballot design and its FPTP status.

      2
    3. @drjjoyner I just don’t think so. It is already a stretch to assume that the math is worth the effort in a plurality contest. That scenario already assumes a substantial level of voter confusion that is highly unlikely (I don’t know for sure, but I am willing to bet that this gamble has never paid off).

      But with Top Four RCV you have to assume a very close race and both substantial voter confusion over the two Dans and a substantial lack of understanding of the process. On top of that double-whammy, you have to assume that those people want to vote for the incumbent but don’t know what the word means and can’t figure it out from the ballot.

      I just don’t see it as a realistic possible outcome at all.

      3
      1. @sltaylor I think there’s been enough attention brought to the “two Dans” issue and that the ballot concessions to have all but eliminated the problem. In the first run, the “other” Dan was listed as a Republican.

        1
  5. Ranked choice voting makes this an utterly baffling and dumb move, but it is inconsequential. Worth noting, I think, that someone recruited a person who is in jail in NYS to run for the congressional seat in Alaska, as a Democrat in 2024–specifically to siphon votes away from Peltola.

    That said, there’s nothing illegal about this, in fact Republicans engage in malicious recruitment all the time.

    3
  6. Charley in Cleveland Avatar
    Charley in Cleveland

    As is the case when the coverup is worse than the crime, this one was a dumb and unnecessary scheme. Senator Dan was ripe to be knocked off, and now the issue isn’t his enabling of Trump, but the Peltola campaign’s skullduggery. Yes, the Alaskan courts cleaned this one up (sufficiently in my estimation), but the fact remains that someone in Peltola’s camp thought Alaskans were dumb enough to fall for a faux Dan Sullivan, and then THEY were dumb enough to follow through with the plan. Dem on Dem crime.

    1
  7. I think it’s basic supply and demand.

    There’s a huge demand for scandal in the media. However, it needs to be the right scandal, and it need to provide days or even weeks of coverage. When lousy people do lousy things, that’s not a scandal. that’s business as usual. And if they do a dozen terrible things every day, that’s not a story you can dissect and interpret for weeks. It’s a five minute wonder before you move on to the next one.

    So, the supply of appropriate scandals is limited. Now comes one from relatively good people who don’t produce such things every other minute. Now you’ve a real scandal. One that can be milked and portioned, and looked at over and over with fresh anger and indignation day after day. Of course the media will pounce on it.

    3
    1. The media also like a scandal they can release when interest is highest, just before the election. In this case, six days before.

      In Comey’s case it was eleven days. I see Nate Silver a few days ago blamed Comey’s release for Hillary’s loss, one on many, of which the absence of any one would turn the result. I will never forgive Comey, nor NYT et al for their breathless coverage of Weiner’s laptop which was obviously going to just be more copies of the same emails. Actually I might forgive Comey if there were a case his hand was forced. NYT never.

      1
  8. The Department of MAGA Justice is reportedly issuing subpoenas.
    Can’t wait to hear what law they imagine is being broken.
    I’m old enough to remember the phony electors scheme though, which was actually felonious.

    3
  9. So great job, Peltola! You have sullied your name in a scheme that is of little use and have helped chip away a bit more at the reputation of American electoral democracy.

    Sure. Peltola sullied her name for a lame scheme, but for this episode to “chip away a bit more on the reputation of American electoral democracy,” it would need some help over the wall by nefarious pundits & pols who don’t value American electoral democracy in the first place. The opposition doesn’t have to play along.

    A sullied Senator Mary Peltola (D) is still much, much better for American democracy than a pristine Senator Dan S Sullivan (R) could be and if she has to bear the Inept Cheater label to get there, so be it.

    And we can’t let the blind partisanship framing be applied here either. In the current state of American electoral democracy, we have one party who is pro-democracy and one party who is pro-authoritarian-minority-rule. Representative government is a non-partisan objective in a democracy. We ought not lose sight of that.

    2
    1. @Scott F.

      A sullied Senator Mary Peltola (D) is still much, much better for American democracy than a pristine Senator Dan S Sullivan (R) could be and if she has to bear the Inept Cheater label to get there, so be it.

      In fairness, nothing I said would contradict that.

      And I agree about the pro-democracy v. pro-authoritarian nature of our politics.

      My frustration about this Dan Sullivan bit is that it is giving ammunition to the pro-authoritarian side.

      It was a foolish thing to do.

  10. Has the regime thanked the failing far-left New York Times for bringing their attention to this matter? It would be the civil thing to do.

    2
    1. @Ken_L It is known that the mainstream press is out to get Trump at all costs!