As sometimes happens, James beat me to the punch (I was writing a post about the Dans Sullivan when I saw he posted one). Let me cut to the chase, leaving James’ post to provide the context: this was a dumb plan and a waste of time with significant negative consequences beyond the Senate race itself.
As I stated in my post on the Trump administration’s lawsuit on this same subject: it makes my brain hurt to figure out under what kind of convoluted scenario having a spoiler on an RCV ballot would be advantageous.
I think a lot of this is that people have First Past the Post Brain and can’t conceive of how electoral rules change the parameters of a contest.
Sure, if in an FPTP election you had a scenario in which Peltola had 49.5% of the vote, Dan S. had 49.4% of the vote, and a handful of voters got confused and voted for Dan J., then the dirty trick pays off.
But since voters can rank their choices, including voting for both Dans, how does any of this help?
I would note that Alaska is a state that managed to successfully elect Lisa Murkowski via a write-in campaign. This suggests an electorate that can distinguish between two Dan Sullivans/read and understand the word “incumbent” on the ballot, because, contrary to what certain people say, most folks know what the word means (or can figure it out from context clues). It even has a “b” in it!

I don’t think that this cunning plan will ultimately matter to the outcome.
However, in addition to being underhanded, it was foolish and counterproductive.
It helps contribute to the general sense that all politicians are corrupt, which gives cover to Trump’s far more significant and far more insidious corruption. This will aid partisans and their motivated reasoning concerning Trump, and it is a far easier-to-understand story for low-information voters than things like how Trump made a ton of money on crypto or how Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff are subverting national security to line their pockets.
Further, it aids Trump strategy of creating deep distrust of American democracy.
So great job, Peltola! You have sullied your name in a scheme that is of little use and have helped chip away a bit more at the reputation of American electoral democracy.









