Peltola Campaign Recruited Other Dan Sullivan

The suspected dirty track has been confirmed.

33

Comments

In my June post “Weak Parties and Dirty Tricks,” I linked and excerpted an AP report on the Alaska Senate race in which incumbent Senator Dan Sullivan and other Republican officials claimed that the presence of a second Republican candidate named Dan Sullivan on the ranked-choice ballot was a dirty trick designed “to rig the election” for former Democratic Representative Mary Peltola. I observed,

I don’t know enough about Alaskan politics or the non-incumbent Dan Sullivan to have a definitive opinion, but this certainly looks like dirty pool on the part of the Peltola campaign. Sowing confusion in voters is a time-honored tactic of both parties, alas, however despicable it may be.

before transitioning to my titular point: this couldn’t have happened in a system where political parties had control over who could run under their banner.

This seemingly obvious conclusion drew extreme pushback in the comment section. Why, how dare I attribute the entry into the race for United States Senator of a rando who had never previously run for political office and who just happened to have the name of the incumbent Republican Senator to the opposition party? Surely, it was just a coincidence!

This morning’s episode of The Daily, “A Plan for Two Dans: How Democrats Manipulated Alaska’s Ballot,” featuring NYT political reporter Kellen Browning, presents rather definitive evidence that the second Sullivan was indeed recruited by the Peltola campaign and that, indeed, there’s good reason to think that the other “Republican” who has survived into the top four, Gerald Heikes, was as well.

It’s based on Browning’s report “Inside Democrats’ Secret Effort to Stack Alaska’s Ballot,” which appears on the front page of today’s print edition (although, oddly, is nowhere to be seen on the main page of their website).

In the summer of 2025, a staffer for Mary Peltola, the Alaska Democrat who was eyeing a run for Senate, received unusual instructions from top campaign aides: Find as many people named Dan Sullivan in Alaska as you can.

The staffer complied, combing through voter records to produce a list of Dan Sullivans from across the state.

This was no random request. Dan S. Sullivan is the name of the state’s Republican senator. And if the Peltola campaign or its allies could track down and persuade another Dan Sullivan to run for Senate, the confusion could cost the senator crucial votes on the state’s unusual, four-person ballot.

The plan worked. This spring, a retired teacher from a tiny fishing village along the Alaska Panhandle, reachable only by air and sea, announced his candidacy for Senate. His name was Dan J. Sullivan.

The Peltola campaign has repeatedly denied any involvement in his candidacy. But The Times has found, based on interviews and text messages, along with documents prepared for a potential lawsuit against the campaign, that not only did Ms. Peltola’s team work with people trying to recruit Mr. Sullivan to run for Senate, but the effort was much broader. The group worked to coax other would-be spoilers into the race, to dilute the incumbent’s support and help catapult the Democrat to victory.

The endeavor, which was internally called the ballot composition project, involved secret trips to far-flung Alaskan communities and the appearance of a mysterious Midwestern operative, who traversed the state using a fake name and made his pitch to would-be candidates over beers at brew pubs.

It also involved the Peltola campaign’s lawyers, as well as senior aides at the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee, which directs the party’s campaign strategy in Senate races across the country. From Washington to Anchorage, those advisers participated in regular conversations about the effort and even considered forming a new political party to draw conservatives onto the ballot.

I doubt the revelations will matter much in how people vote. But the whole thing is despicable.

33 responses to “Peltola Campaign Recruited Other Dan Sullivan”

  1. As Dr. Taylor reminds us regularly, this entire effort should be a wash under Alaska’s ranked choice voting so long as confused conservative voters know to vote for every conservative candidate. I am surprised Peltola’s campaign spent so much energy on it.

    3
  2. It is not great that the Peltola campaign ginned this up though it is a pretty common tactic.

    https://bsky.app/profile/paulwaldman.bsky.social/post/3myzcoew65s2r

    “The Dan Sullivans Affair is underhanded, of course, but this has happened a number of times before. Just 4 years ago Republicans found a guy named Mike Doyle to run for the seat of retiring Democratic Rep. Mike Doyle”

    But it seems like in a ranked vote state it really should have very, very minimal effect, if any. I mean, if you want Dan Sullivan-R incumbent, just rank all Dan Sullivans as the non incumbent will drop out of the count quickly.

    2
    1. On the ballot, the Dan Sullivan that is R-incumbent is clearly identified as such. The other Dan Sullivan has no indicated affiliation or status at all.

      1
      1. Right. Understand. So even if you were confused about which one to vote for to reelect the incumbent (and you don’t know what that word means or see it on the ballet), you can just vote for all the Dan Sullivans and it will work out fine.

        1
      2. @Michael Cain: This was a late move to counter the deception. The other Dan Sullivan was initially listed as a Republican. Listing the incumbent as “Dan” instead of “Daniel” and adding the incumbent tag was done to help ameliorate the confusion.

    2. Thank you. I thought I’d heard of this being done before.

  3. I won’t claim this is right or even smart, but remember the most important rule of politics: it’s wrong only when the other party does it.

    Gerrymandering mid-decade, trying to access voter rolls, suing in favor of one candidate before the election, attempting to disenfranchise voters on vague grounds, meddling with the post office so it slows down delivery of mail in ballots, and lots more.

    Not that this hasn’t been discussed and condemned here. It has been. But weigh the Alaska Democrats’ dirty trick against the other side’s dirty tricks.

    2
    1. @Kathy Sure. But Senate races aren’t gerrymandered. And, as undemocratic as gerrymandering is, it’s at least transparent. Peltola’s campaign has repeatedly lied about their involvement in this.

  4. It may be useful to consider some of the context in which this is occuring. The partisan split of Alaska’s registered voters is 11.6% Democratic, 22.9% Republican, and 63.8% unaffiliated. The “majorities” running both chambers of the Alaska legislature are coalitions of Democrats, Republicans, and independents. The top-four primary and ranked-choice ballot were installed by ballot initiative in 2020. Sen. Murkowski retained her seat despite the opposition of the Alaskan Republican Party due to top-four plus ranked choice. An initiative to revert to the typical partisan arrangement failed in 2024. There’s a similar initiative to revert on the ballot this year.

    It’s certainly tempting to interpret the situation as Alaska’s unaffiliated voters saying that they want parties out of the arrangement entirely.

    1. @michael cain: Except that “Alaska’s unaffiliated voters” didn’t do this; the Peltola campaign did.

      1. I didn’t intend to suggest that anyone but the Peltola campaign did anything underhanded. I only intended to point out that the voters in Alaska, and the unaffiliated voters in particular by virtue of their number, installed a system that made parties even weaker and shenanigans like this trivially easy. Having skimmed through the Alaska statutes and the FEC’s web site, it appears that setting up a (mandatory) political committee that meets the FEC’s requirements is by far the hardest part of the job.

  5. This post has me doing some soul searching. I was one of those providing “extreme pushback” on the grounds of the absence of evidence. Now that there is reporting providing evidence, how do I think about this now?

    Surely, this underhanded action bolsters the “both sides are cheats” argument. That’s a shame, but we’ve learned asymmetry in the scale/scope of the cheating is irrelevant and pointing out hypocrisy is completely toothless. So, there’s a notch on the Dem side of the cheaters ledger and the bothsiders will make hay with that.

    But, in the end, my preferred partisan affiliation is Pragmatist and this makes me want Peltola to win even more. The country needs the forces for liberal democracy to win in order to get better governance. If the electoral structure incentivizes dirty tricks, then I guess I find a willingness to take the gloves off attractive in this moment.

    1
    1. I would add to your thought a question about which party is more likely to address election dirty tricks?

      Only the dems have proposed doing away nationally with gerrymandering. And it was the GOP leader who did 1/6.

      So if want less of this kind of stuff, elect good government dems.

    2. @Scott F. Someone who works this hard to cheat to win an election may be many things, but part of “the forces for liberal democracy” is not among them.

      1. “cheat” is a very loaded term in this context when one sees the actions of the administration in CA and WA. Given all the prior Dans media coverage, the design of the ballot, the AK SC case and RCV it seems more like they were trying to game the system in a very dubious effort.

        More like a bad bluff in poker than using marked cards.

        1
      2. OMG, James. You’re proving my point on asymmetry and my new found appreciation for Peltola.

        Here’s a thought experiment.

        Put “Peltola’s campaign working this hard on ballot stacking” on a scale measuring impact to liberal democracy opposite “President Trump calling for criminal charges and removal of Peltola from the ballot for this same ballot stacking.” Put Despicably Illiberal on one side of the scale and Acceptably Liberal on the other. I’m super confident I know which way the balance will tip. Aren’t you?

        Unilateral disarmament on political gamesmanship in a battle with a Trumpist GOP that doesn’t believe in any rules and considers itself above the law ain’t winning any points for my cause. Sometimes the moment calls for a change in tactics.

        3
  6. This is the line in the sand where you wield the word “despicable”. That word should have been used previously for so many things the current people in power have done to this country. Admittedly, the same-name candidate ploy is overtly juvenile. However, compared to the multi-level $#1+ storm we are currently experiencing, we can’t afford to give one wit about it in comparison.

    1. Yeah, “despicable” is a bit too fainting couch for me. This tactic is not new, Dems and Republicans have done it before in varying ways. Alaska Republicans once got an inmate on the ballot to try to siphon votes from Pelota. Just this week we got more reporting on Republican megadonors elevating fringe candidates like Cornel West. It’s unseemly, but it’s also very typical. Despicable? Eh, take some smelling salts and calm down.

      If I was an Alaska voter, I’d be pretty disturbed about the Peltola camp’s dogged lying about their involvement. That would irritate me more than the tactic itself. But I also suspect I’m an outlier and that it’s the kind of thing that matters more to political junkies than to our low info electorate. A country full of three-time Trump voters doesn’t care too much about sleaze or dirty tricks.

      7
  7. Worth noting that Eric Hafner, an imprisoned felon in NY, ran as a Democrat in Alaska in 2024.

    “Mr. Hafner has been a fringe congressional candidate at least twice before: in Hawaii in 2016 as a Republican and in Oregon two years later as a Democrat. This year, his Alaska candidacy withstood Democratic challenges in two courts and has pundits discussing the national implications of his possibly tipping the race, which could be key to control of the House.”

    And then, there’s this:

    “Alaska is no stranger to fringe candidates, and neither is Ms. Peltola. In the nonpartisan primary in 2022, she handily defeated Santa Claus — yes, it’s his legal name — an independent from North Pole, Alaska, who received nearly 5 percent of the vote.”

    Yes, stronger parties with more control over candidate selection would eliminate some of this. But there is a fair amount of malicious recruitment going on, and Alaska seems more f*cked up on this count than most states.

    1
  8. “In the summer of 2025, a staffer for Mary Peltola,…”

    I’m guessing that the campaign staff involved would now mostly agree that it was foolish to recruit republican spoilers. But at the time, Peltola had left her previous elected seat six months earlier, and would not announce her candidacy for the Senate until six months later. Whatever the Peltola campaign consisted of in the summer of ’25, they were a long-shot to win in the fall of ’26…until the effects of tariffs and poor governance and ultimately the fallout from the war in Iran. Still a dumb thing to do, and not the kind of thing that can be kept secret.

    1
  9. Just to be contrary…

    Trump and his cabal have flouted norms and legal compliance and gotten away with it, thus lowering the bar on morality and legal compliance. Or have they? Perhaps they only lowered the bar for Republicans?

    Republicans are rolling out their October surprises, which I’m sure they have been planning for months.

    Once again, Democrats will probably police their own and condemn the alleged stacking of the ballot. Let me see…I can’t remember when the Republicans policed members of their party.

    I wish I were a better person and willing to sacrifice the welfare of our country on altar of morality and the rule of law, as I have all of my adult life up to this moment.

    But damn, I’m weary, scared, and angry. It’s hard to muster the willpower to do so.

    And Dr. Joyner, I don’t believe you were quite so upset about this.

    If this were a declared civil war, wouldn’t deception and confusion be acceptable tactics?

    The campaign was stupid to have set themselves up, but why must the Democrats always have operate with one hand tied behind their back?

    I truly morally confused.

    2
    1. Democrats will probably police their own and condemn the alleged stacking of the ballot.

      Some tepid criticism of Peltola’s dishonesty wouldn’t be ill-advised, but it would be silly for Dems to help feed fake outrage. What we should do is prep for a little fake outrage or our own, when Republicans inevitably again funnel resources and money to Jill Stein and Cornel West in 2028. Scream election interference and ballot stacking and call for subpoenas and all that.

      1
      1. Unfortunately, Democrats have funded Republican candidates, too. And that points to the weakness of my original post:

        If we lose the moral and legal compliance high ground, how can we prosecute Republicans?

        Do the ends justify the means?

        1. Democrats have funded Republican candidates

          Yes, I know. My first comment above says so.

          If we lose the moral and legal compliance high ground, how can we prosecute Republicans?

          Easy, by applying the law. There’s no clause that says only saints can prosecute criminals.

          Until Democrats regularly start electing pedophiles who incite terror attacks on Congress, Democrats are not going to lose any moral and political high ground. This kind of ballot trickery — in which, as we note, both major parties regularly partake — is tawdry. But it is not a moral crisis. (Now Peltola’s dishonesty on the subject, that is an ethical hurdle for her. The coverup was worse than the offense here, but curiously, that’s somehow not what Peltola’s critics are focused on.)

          Now if Democrats had, in 2026, rallied behind Graham Platner after he was very credibly accused of rape by a Dem staffer, I’d be concerned about moral backsliding. But we didn’t, we told him to take a hike despite great political risk and uncertainty, and then shouted down our allies who wanted to keep him.

          2
  10. The president of the USA uses the DOJ to demand that the Alaskan senatorial election be voided unless his chosen candidate wins, and this silly bit of ratfucking is what gets Dr. Joyner into a moral tizzy.

    3
    1. @wr Trump’s obvious moral bankruptcy led me to abandon the political party for whose presidential candidates I voted from 1984-2012 in favor of my least favorite Democratic nominee in my lifetime and her two successors. I’ve condemned, within the limits my livelihood can sustain, his efforts to undermine the current election. That doesn’t require me to ignore Democrats likewise taking underhanded attempts to undermine democracy.

      1. I left the Republican party long ago over the Iran-Contra affair. I was never a fan of Ronald Reagan, especially after the Beirut barracks attack, which I place firmly in his lap.

        I’m glad that Trump finally persuaded you to change parties, but my sense that you still think of Trump is an aberration, not a monster for whom Lee Atwater, Roger Stone, Paul Manafort, Roy Cohn, and others created the conditions in which he was able to come into power and thrive.

        Anger masks fear, and the tone of the this article suggests you were really angry when you wrote it, which, as others have noted, is puzzling.

        1
      2. By any measure this amounts to political tomfoolery, when in comparison there are actual criminals and ghouls running the government and currently using the levers of power to undermine our elections. It’s way past the time to recalibrate the internal sensor that trips the use of the word “despicable”.

  11. Didn’t Old Joe Kennedy pull a similar stunt to get JFK elected to Congress?

    1
  12. I have to ask: at what point do slimy tactics shift from “politics ain’t beanbag” to “despicable”?

    The NYT has, rather belatedly IMHO, posted this:

    Third-Party Spoilers, Long Fueled by Both Parties, Could Matter This Year

    While it’s a gift link, I’ll add some highlights:

    “In Ohio, Republicans have spent more than $2.2 million to promote a socialist candidate in the state’s vital Senate race, aiming to pull votes from the Democratic nominee, former Senator Sherrod Brown.”
    […]
    “In Virginia, a Republican group has sent mailers highlighting the Democratic-leaning positions of a self-described “radical centrist” running as an independent in a competitive House race.”
    […]
    “And in Nebraska, both major parties are jockeying to help minor candidates peel votes away from Senator Pete Ricketts, the Republican incumbent, and his Democratic-backed independent challenger, Dan Osborn.”

    Let’s add on top of that pile, GOP work to promote Cornel West, and a very suspicious sudden interest in running for Congress from a Republican with the same name as the retiring Democrat.

    Then, of course, we have the usual nonsense like the highly deceptive mailer that was sent out in Texas, that misleadingly implied it was from an existing trans group but wasn’t.

    The ratio here, for anyone keeping track, is 6 underhanded tactics from Republicans, 2 from Democrats.

    Interesting.

    5
  13. Oh my, Peltola got caught with her hand in the cookie jar, if it costs her the senate seat, it’s her own fault. No need to go all Capt. Renault, politics can be a rough occupation.

    2
  14. It’s always “both sides do it,” unless actually both sides do it.

    1
  15. I don’t think the story will have much of an impact since we have all become politically cynical, but I don’t like it. I will ad that Peltola denies any knowledge and the main source could be a disgruntled fired employee who then withdrew her statements. The story itself is not as solid as could be. The question being who was actually involved, and since nothing illegal happened, we probably will not find out the full story.