Source: Official White House Photo

Trump at 80

How old is too old for the most powerful job on the planet?

14
Source: Official White House Photo

Donald J. Trump’s birthday is today, making him America’s second octogenarian president. Naturally, folks are reflecting on the milestone.

AP (“Trump turns 80 with a showstopping spectacle of cage fights at the White House. But big issues loom.”):

President Donald Trump celebrates turning 80 on Sunday with a showstopping birthday spectacle that once would have seemed unfathomable: a cage-fighting show on the storied South Lawn of the White House.

This week, the hard realities of the office have threatened to overshadow the ostentatious UFC mixed martial arts extravaganza, where combatants sealed inside a wire-mesh octagon try to punch, kick, chop and pummel each other into submission.

Trump has found himself boxed into an unpopular and costly war he helped start in Iran. An agreement to end the conflict could be close, but the crucial details are still to be negotiated. Meanwhile, about a mile from Trump’s birthday bash, crews pried the president’s name off the Kennedy Center after a judge ruled naming it after Trump had gone too far.

Regardless, the president will walk out of the White House and be surrounded by Cabinet leaders, top administration officials, Republican lawmakers and 4,000-plus spectators screaming themselves hoarse in a temporary arena under “ The Claw,” a spaceship-like metal arch fitted with lighting, sound equipment and large screens. Thousands more will be watching on big screens from the nearby Ellipse.

“This event is a one of one event, incredible event. I love it,” said UFC chief Dana White, a close friend of the president, during a Friday night hype session at the Lincoln Memorial where pairs of fighters shoved and scuffled for the cameras under the stoic gaze of Honest Abe’s marble likeness.

NYT, (“Trump at 80: A President ‘Really Uncomfortable’ With Aging“):

He stays up late, phoning lawyers and lawmakers, while posting up to 150 times a night on Truth Social. His mornings involve calls with world leaders about the war in the Middle East, or talks with landscapers about replanting a bothersome tree. When he arrives in the Oval Office, his unstructured days unfold like a time-lapse video, with people zipping around him as he stays seated at the center of the frame.

As President Trump turns 80 on Sunday, he is so intent on projecting an image of relentless energy that he has installed a massive, mixed martial arts octagon on the South Lawn to mark the occasion. After watching the fight, Mr. Trump will depart Washington in the middle of the night and cross an ocean for a diplomatic summit in France. It is a schedule that seems devised to ward off questions about age and stamina as he begins his ninth decade.

[…]

Earlier this month, legions of online observers speculated, as they had before, that Mr. Trump was ailing when his public schedule contained no public events for nearly a week, a streak that began just after a physical exam at Walter Reed National Military Medical Center. Three days after that evaluation was completed, the president’s physician, Dr. Sean P. Barbabella, declared in a summary that the 79-year-old Mr. Trump “remains in excellent health, demonstrating strong cardiac, pulmonary, neurological and overall physical function.”

So the oldest president ever to be inaugurated and his advisers spend a lot of time hitting back at people who have drawn a different set of conclusions about his health based on what they believe they can plainly see.

[…]

“The White House doctors are among the most elite physicians in the world, and they have released multiple comprehensive reports confirming President Trump is in excellent health and fully fit to carry out all duties of commander in chief,” Karoline Leavitt, the White House press secretary, said in a statement. “The president proves this himself every single day, taking nonstop questions from a hostile press corps and maintaining a relentless schedule.”

[…]

Mr. Trump is part of a class of Washington politicians who have remained in power even as Americans have signaled concerns about aging leaders. Washington is a part-time home to the third-oldest Congress in history, and if Mr. Trump completes his term at age 82, he will be the oldest president to have held office.

“Somebody at 80 years old just doesn’t have the physical stamina, the mental stamina for that office,” said Rahm Emanuel, a prominent Democrat who is interested in running for president in 2028, and who has called for a mandatory retirement age of 75 for many top federal positions. Mr. Emanuel, who served as a chief of staff to President Barack Obama and a top aide to President Bill Clinton, said that the presidency is especially taxing.

“It ages you in a way that no other stress in your life does,” he said.

Some White Houses have been more aggressive than others at obscuring the truth of an aging president’s condition. As President Joseph R. Biden Jr. physically declined, his aides went to great lengths to obscure the signs of his aging. No one in Mr. Biden’s inner circle discouraged him from trying to run for the presidency again, despite indications that he was growing more frail.

As he ages, Mr. Trump has taken a different approach. He lets the cameras pick up his slumps, swollen ankles and bandaged hand. He continues to take a tall stairway wheeled up to Air Force One, often navigating the stairs carefully. He continues to appear before the news media, fielding questions from friendlier faces and lashing out at journalists who ask him questions he perceives as unflattering.

More often than not, he meanders far beyond the topic he has appeared before reporters to discuss.

The Independent (“The oldest elected US president is turning 80, but it’s not Trump’s age that has medical experts worried“):

President Donald Trump turns 80 on Sunday, following more than a year of exhibiting visible symptoms typical for an octogenarian, including bruising on his hands, swollen ankles and legs, and appearing to nod off during meetings and high-profile events.

Medical experts warn, though, that it’s not so much these obvious symptoms and his age that Americans should be most concerned about, but the conduct and behavior on display during his second presidency.

“It’s not that he’s 80, but let’s not ignore the red flags on the field,” Dr. Henry Abraham, a Nobel Prize-winning professor of Psychiatry Emeritus at Tufts University School of Medicine, told The Independent. “There are people in their 80s and 90s who have all their marbles.”

But Abraham, who stressed he has never examined the president in person and was not offering a diagnosis, is seriously alarmed that Trump has access to the nuclear codes.

“If you just look at everything that he’s said and done, and has been observed doing over, really, decades, certain signs and symptoms emerge which are warning flags regarding the conduct of his presidency going forward,” he said.

“Poor impulse control, poor control over his rage, sleeplessness at night, unrelenting aggression toward his perceived enemies,” Abraham said. “Well, put all that together and give him the nuclear football, and you can see why we’re worried.”

David Smith, The Guardian (“As Donald Trump turns 80, he faces a foe he can never defeat: Father Time. That’s a problem for us all“):

The main Nuremberg trial ended, Winston Churchill warned of an iron curtain descending across Europe, It’s a Wonderful Life received its premiere and, at Jamaica hospital in the borough of Queens, New York, Donald John Trump was born.

It was 1946, also the birth year of George W Bush and Bill Clinton, but on Sunday the current US president celebrates his 80th birthday in a style uniquely his own. Trump will stage a night of cage fighting on the once-pristine White House south lawn as part of events marking the 250th anniversary of US independence.

The blend of visceral bloodsport with political spectacle under metal scaffolding may offer brief respite for a president also consumed with an unpopular war, rising inflation, plunging poll numbers and a foe not even he can bully, bomb or outrun: Father Time.

“Donald Trump has been showing signs of his age for quite some time,” said Tara Setmayer, a former Republican communications director on Capitol Hill. “It’s on display almost daily as he struggles to stay awake during official meetings, he is more irritable and going on rage tangents and throwing temper tantrums when he doesn’t get his way. These are not signs of a well-adjusted adult approaching 80 years old.”

[…]

The physical evidence is increasingly difficult for his aides to conceal, though they aggressively project a narrative of vigour. The president has been photographed with bruised hands and swollen ankles, ailments his medical staff continually brush off as a “slight” issue. He sees 22 medical specialists, an apparent new bar for presidents.

His public calendar has grown notably sparse, dominated by hours of nebulous “executive time” and behind-closed-doors policy meetings. After a flurry of travel early in the year, he has largely retreated to the cocoons of the White House and his clubs in Florida and New Jersey since launching the Iran war in February.

Then there is the sleeping. Trump has increasingly been caught on camera apparently nodding off at public events, most recently at an NBA basketball finals game at New York’s Madison Square Garden. When clips of his shut eyes go viral, his aides claim he was merely blinking or listening intently.

The White House spokesperson Davis Ingle has insisted that Trump remains “the sharpest and most accessible president in American history”. The president himself frequently boasts of “acing” cognitive tests that would have flummoxed past presidents.

But to observers the spin is not only unconvincing but counterproductive. Kurt Bardella, a political commentator and former congressional aide, said: “It’s not surprising that someone who’s on the doorstep of being octogenarian is showing signs of ageing. Father Time is undefeated: that applies to everybody including Donald Trump and I would have more confidence in him as commander-in chief if he would just admit that rather than try to hide it.”

Bardella added: “Hiding it is a sign of weakness. Being transparent, forthright, honest about it would actually be a sign a strength. The fact the White House seems to be going to all these ridiculous and laughable measures to try to convince us that he’s not actually ageing is insulting to American people, it’s idiotic, it reeks of desperation, and it makes everyone believe that there’s more going on than meets the eye. And what meets the eye isn’t that great. Secrecy breeds mistrust.”

It’s noteworthy how little Trump’s age has been discussed compared to his predecessor. While Biden was more physically fit, he was also more gaunt, making him look older. He was also relatively pale, while Trump is famously spray-tanned.

It’s my longstanding view that politicians ought to step off the stage before they become geriatric. It was decidedly not a good thing for the presidency and most of the Congressional leadership to be in the hands of octogenarians a few years back. In addition to the inevitable decline in mental sharpness and energy, people simply lose touch at some point.

But it’s not as though people didn’t know how old Joe Biden was in 2020 or Donald Trump was in 2024. In the last election, in particular, Americans had the option to choose a much younger candidate (Harris is just 61) and did not.

14 responses to “Trump at 80”

  1. Normally, the presidency ages officeholders quickly, but that is because of the weight of the office, the responsibilities and concerns that most presidents have for the well-being of the country, and the historical importance of the role.

    Trump suffers from none of this.

    When you don’t care, then the office doesn’t particularly age you.

    9
  2. I’m six weeks older than Trump. I’m in better shape mentally and physically and a deal smarter (like almost everyone). There’s no way I, or he, should be prez.

    10
  3. In addition to the maladies listed above in the articles, he is increasingly seated when cameras arrive. In short, they are not filming him walking or standing. Something is definitely going on, and we’re being kept in the dark about it, and yep, the press is far less fixated on his ailments than they were Biden’s.

    9
  4. @Jen: You’re violating the NYT style guide which would require, “the press is far less fixated on Donald J. Trump’s ailments than they were on those of Joseph R. Biden, 83.”

    10
  5. The satirist Andy Borowitz, who usually writes Onion-style fake news, the other day stated something that was, uncharacteristically, 100% true, though I was previously unaware of it.

    “As Trump celebrates turning 80 this Sunday, it’s worth noting that he shares the same birthday as the legendary German neurologist Alois Alzheimer (1864-1915).”

    7
  6. When people talk about Trump’s cognitive decline, one point I think that gets lost is that age-related cognitive decline often leads to preexisting mental-health issues becoming more pronounced.

    I saw this in my own family with my maternal grandmother and OCD. One time, I received an article from her that she thought might interest me. By “article,” I mean a clipping she cut out of a newspaper, using scissors. This was in the 2000s. I told her I liked the article. That validation I gave her, which honestly I don’t regret, led her into a Sorcerer’s Apprentice-like spiral of sending me endless newspaper clippings, something she had in the roomfuls. (The Sorcerer’s Apprentice is an analogy I have frequently used when describing the OCD experience in members of my family, including myself.) Every time I visited her, she would give me this giant stack of newspaper clippings for my perusal, each one probably enough material for a short book. At my parents’ suggestion, as soon as we left the apartment we went down to the garbage room and disposed of it–which made me feel awful, because I know how hurt she’d have been if she ever found out what we did with it. But there was no way I was going to read everything in these stacks, and they just introduced clutter.

    In Trump’s case, what’s become pronounced in old age is the narcissism that was always there.

    It reminds me of an old Bill Cosby routine containing slightly saltier-than-usual language for him, where someone tells him that what’s great about cocaine is that it intensifies one’s personality, and he replies, “But what if you’re an asshole?”

    (Cosby certainly would know.)

    6
  7. But it’s not as though people didn’t know how old Joe Biden was in 2020 or Donald Trump was in 2024. In the last election, in particular, Americans had the option to choose a much younger candidate (Harris is just 61) and did not.

    I’m a confessed ageist, so I agree with your premise that politicians ought to step off the stage before they become geriatric. That said, if you’re going to use comparisons of Biden and Trump as an argument on fitness for office at 80, age has NOTHING to do with it.

    In his advanced years, Biden (with his administration) shepherded significant legislation into law (the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law, the CHIPS and Science Act, the Inflation Reduction Act, et al), demonstrated true statesmanship in rallying NATO against Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, and led an economic recovery from COVID-flation that was the envy of other world leaders. He was the best President for unions in my lifetime.

    Trump’s unfitness for POTUS was preordained when he was in his twenties.

    Biden was a one-termer not because his age prevented him from being a good president, but because he showed his age in a debate (the least important thing a politician does in terms of governance), he was flying against anti-incumbent headwinds, and because our political press favors entertainment over honest information.

    19
  8. @Scott F.:

    I agree with you about Biden’s accomplishments during crisis. He is also a decent man. But I disagree with this comment:

    Biden was a one-termer not because his age prevented him from being a good president, but because he showed his age in a debate (the least important thing a politician does in terms of governance), he was flying against anti-incumbent headwinds, and because our political press favors entertainment over honest information.

    In my recollection, he promised that (or at least suggested) he would be a one-term president. With no primary system that tested both him and younger contenders in the public eye for the next presidential election, we were left with a disaster for our country when his decline became evident in his debate performance. I witnessed both of my parents becoming imperious as they aged, so I believe it was ingenious of his family and staff to pretend all was well in terms of his neurological health.

    I was never a Biden fan, but he stepped up and defeated Trump 45 and led us through the COVID pandemic. How much grander his legacy would be if he, like George Washington, had known when it was time pass the reins and step aside.

    6
  9. @Jen: I, for one, am enjoying his slow death in the public eye. It adds drama. And even if they’ve hidden the seriousness from him, or he has failed to understand it, he has to know how much less he can do.

    And he gets to see his attempts at putting his name on everything failing, with the Kennedy center shedding his name like a bad skin condition flaking off.

    Maybe it will happen today.

    6
  10. His baseline was so awful I think it makes it harder to see the difference as he ages. Maybe he says bizarre, stupid things more often but he already set expectations so it’s not as easy to see. Plus his cult has already been primed to prepare rationalizations for anything he says or does, if they arent actually cheering him on.

    Steve

    3
  11. @Skookum:

    How much grander his legacy would be if he, like George Washington, had known when it was time pass the reins and step aside.

    This would have been my preferred outcome as well, but that goes to James’ point about geriatrics in governance and not the sub-header question of “how old is too old for POTUS?”

    When I voted for Old Man Joe in 2020, I got more than I expected. (And since I believe that POTUS is a head of government and not a king, I think his administration could have kept it up, or at least passed the baton to Harris, in the second term.)

    When I voted against Old Man Trump in 2016, 2020, and 2024, it was because I didn’t want that MAGA clown anywhere near the White House at 70, 74, or 78 years of age.

    6
  12. Trump is big mad the “peace deal” (i.e., MOU) will not be signed today because he really really wanted it signed for his June 14 birthday.

    3
  13. It’s not the age it’s the incompetence. He was incompetent during his first term. He was incompetent when he went bankrupt 6 times. He was incompetent when he squandered his $400M inheritance.
    The incompetence is staggering.

    12

Trending