Photo by SLT

Tuesday’s Forum

30

Comments

OTB relies on its readers to support it. Please consider helping by becoming a monthly contributor through Patreon or making a one-time contribution via PayPal. Thanks for your consideration.

30 responses to “Tuesday’s Forum”

  1. The Democrats on the House Judiciary Committee released a report on the connections between Epstein and Trump.

    Some tidbits:

    Above all, the actual evidence we have seen—as shared in the accounts and stories of 11 women, each described below—indicates that Trump abused, assaulted, and even raped numerous women alongside, and in coordination with, the most infamous sex trafficker in history.

    In total, more than 25 different women—some connected to Epstein and many not—have independently accused Donald Trump of rape, sexual assault, or other sexual misconduct.

    The terrible thing is that we already knew this. There is (in the public record) the Jean Carroll case, the “grab-em-by-the pussy” remark, the Miss Teen dressing room incident, the Epstein birthday card, the Ivana testimony, the active interference with releasing the Epstein files, etc. It just goes on and on and on.

    And this is the kind of moral character that most conservatives are (at best) willing to overlook, or (at worst) are actively embracing.

    These people are sick. Every single one of therm a complete and utter moral degenerate.

    2
  2. Charley in Cleveland Avatar
    Charley in Cleveland

    @drj The Stormy Davis related 34 felonies are the equivalent of Al Capone’s failure to pay taxes, which is to say the very least of the wrongs committed by an amoral wannabe mobster. The difference is that Capone was smart enough to stay out of politics.

  3. A lot seems to be happening in the oil producing Gulf. AlJazeera reports that Turkiye, Saudi Arabia, Pakistan, and Iran are meeting in Tehran. Qatar and Iran are meeting in Moscow. The USA is getting marginalized since our weapons are clearly less effective than advertised and our ideas are laughable. Trump has brought us down.

    3
    1. W took a chunk off The American Century and Trump seems determined to kill what’s left.

      And whatever the effectiveness of our weapons, we can’t be trusted to deliver and support them, may even switch them off.

      1
    2. The Ukrainians are rather impressed with the effectiveness of some US weapons.
      The difference seems to be the Ukrainians are smart about using them, and don’t fire off top-line interceptors at drones and decoys.

      But the main point remains as you say: if the the US is an ineffective, unreliable, and rather frivolous, ally, its partners will seek other options.
      This applies far more widely than just the Middle East.

      2
    3. I tend to assume weapons systems work more or less as advertised. The issue is whether such systems are the right tool against a given opponent.

      I’ve a really sharp chef’s knife I use a great deal. I’ve no doubt I could peel a carrot with it. A vegetable peeler, though much less sharp, would make for a faster task with less waste.

      Perhaps the US interceptor missiles are not the right tool against a swarm of drones. And we’ve known for a long time you can’t take or hold territory with air power alone.

      The way I see it, the plan was for a decapitation strike, which BTW was eminently successful, to win the war. This did not happen, and there doesn’t seem to have been a contingency plan.

      If the “plan” was “hope the people rise up and take over the government,” I can think of few situations where that has led to a military victory. Perhaps the October Revolution in Russia.

      1
      1. Precisely.
        Ukraine has learnt long since to use other systems (interceptor drones, systems-guided guns, lower-grade missiles, etc) to counter drones.
        The whole “decapitation strike” concept was folly, as it’s long been known the IRGC has distributed its command structure.
        The IRGC may be bastards, but they are not stupid bastards.

        Popular uprisings can win (I haz a list 😉 ), but not likely if the regime has prepped for it, has overwhelming firepower, and a lot of personnel who know that certainly their privileges, and probably their necks, depend upon being prepared to massacre any rebels.

        1
        1. Not to mention if you’re counting on an uprising, you arm the rebels ahead of time. Guns and explosives, of course, but also intel, medical supplies, coms, and vehicles.

          The decapitation strike is like a toddler’s notion of how to win a war, mixed with the cinematic climax of the big battle. I say this because I recall asking my teachers in elementary school what an army needs to win a war. I though of things like killing the other side’s president, or taking over their capital.

          3
      2. One of the lessons of Ukraine-Russia is that the Russian S-300 and S-400 air defense systems are nowhere near as good as the Russians advertised (and the Pentagon assumed for their planning).

        1. The S-300’s seem oddly to have been reasonably effective for Ukraine, not so much for Russia.
          The likelihood is that Ukrainians, being the inveterate tinkerers that they are, have been able to upgrade the systems.

        2. Inveterate tinkerers of the world, unite!

          1
  4. Reply to Kathy:
    Revolutionary uprising have won.
    Revolutionary uprisings winning in a country not occupied by an external Power, and in support of an external Power?
    I can’t think of any at all.
    Closest might be some Spanish episodes, but there local particularism was a factor.

    1. I thought the October Revolution gave Germany a way to stop fighting on the eastern front. But before that happened, the Kerenski regime kept up the fight as much as the Czar had.

      Some uprisings have helped third party powers to improve their strategic posture, perhaps. Even this is chancy. Did support for the American rebels yielded hard results for France vis a vis England? It ultimately delivered Louis XVI a revolution.

      Now, had El Taco instigated an armed, well equipped revolt in Iran, and then sent in troops and air strikes in support, that might have amounted to something. And it would have been expensive in blood and treasure. it would also have been hard to arm an equip tens to hundreds of thousands while the Mad Mullahs ran the country.

      It must be, as I keep saying, we do not live in an action movie.

      1. It did give the Germans that chance (hence their benign atitude to the Bolsheviks until they had taken power), but the Reichswehr remained determined to control the occupied areas, so never redirected all forces westward.
        But the Bolsheviks were never open allies of Germany.

        In the American Revolution, the rebels had come to see the British as an external enemy, thus France as an external ally..
        And the British partly decided to cut their losses in the Colonies in order to give the French a good kicking elsewhere.

        Iran never seems to have had an opposition capable of organising sufficiently in the face of the secret police, and the overwhelming firepower and personal interest of the IRGC and Basij structures.

      2. dazedandconfused Avatar
        dazedandconfused

        Key was the mobilization of Russia to fight the Germans, the peasants and serfs had rifles and bullets instead of pitchforks when they were seriously, even desperately, pissed off by the incompetence of their officers and generals.

        1
        1. In part, yes.
          But the streams of the Russian revolutions of 1917 are quite complicated. The army collapsed, but how far it then enacted revolution, especially Bolshevik revolution, is more arguable, imo.
          Tsardom had recovered from military disaster before.
          A lot of the army enlisted ended up fighting against the Bolsheviks; the hard core of Leninist control was the centralised organised Party that gained control of the “soviets” of striking workers and key military units.

          That is a factor that had been absent in previous crises; the combination of external war disaster, economic near-collapse, and a dedicated, disciplined and ruthless revolutionary cadre intent on seizing and retaining control by whatever means necessary.
          While the often non- (or even anti-) Bolshevik movements destroyed existing social structures in industry and the country estates.

          But, neither the Bolsheviks nor any other key actors, saw themselves as allies of the Germans in overthrowing either the Tsarist state or the September Republic.

          1
        2. dazedandconfused Avatar
          dazedandconfused

          John SF,

          I’m surprised, but the AI dreck on this struck me as pretty good:

          1. Disintegration of State Authority and the Proved Failure of the Provisional Government

          • The Kerensky Offensive: The post-Tsarist Provisional Government (led by Alexander Kerensky) chose to continue the war, launching a disastrous military offensive in June 1917. Its brutal failure caused massive front-line routs, crushed morale, and proved to the public that the new government could not—or would not—solve the crisis.
          • Power Vacuum: As detailed by Britannica, the complete breakdown of military discipline (accelerated by measures like Order No. 1) left the Provisional Government with no loyal, functioning coercive apparatus to defend itself when the Bolsheviks struck in November (October Revolution).

          Radicalization and Mass Desertion of Soldiers

          • Turning Soldiers into Revolutionaries: By late 1917, nearly two million war-weary Russian soldiers had deserted the front lines, taking their weapons with them.
          • The “Peace, Land, and Bread” Appeal: The Bolsheviks under Vladimir Lenin aggressively championed an immediate end to the war. Deserters and active troops alike—exhausted by slaughter, cold, and starvation—gravitated toward the Bolshevik message.
          • Armed Force on the Ground: Returning soldiers did not just go home quietly; many used their arms to seize land from the nobility in the countryside or joined Red Guard militias in cities like Petrograd and Moscow, giving the Bolsheviks a ready-made, armed paramilitary base.

          Fulfilling the Promise of Exit from the War

          • Immediate Armistice: Once the Bolsheviks executed their coup in November 1917, Lenin immediately issued the Decree on Peace and pulled Russia out of the war.
          • Legitimacy Among the War-Weary: By formally ending the slaughter—even at the steep territorial cost of the Treaty of Brest-Litovsk in March 1918—the Bolsheviks delivered on their core promise, neutralizing the biggest grievance that had doomed both the Tsar and the Provisional Government.
          Would you like to explore how the Bolsheviks transformed these scattered soldiers into the Red Army during the Russian Civil War, or look more closely at the impact of the Treaty of Brest-Litovsk?

  5. Actress Susan Saint James, 80, has died. RIP.

    1
  6. Democrats exhaust me sometimes. This is apparently a post from X (which I no longer have an account on, so cannot verify), by Amanda Litman, a co-founder of Run for Something.

    I have to ask: what is the POINT of “run for something” if winning is a problem?

    This comes on the heels of an overly dramatic navel-gazing piece posted on LitHub titled “How Joe Biden and the National Democratic Party Paved the Way for American Fascism.”

    It’s fine to ask questions. No party is perfect, and yes, there’s a lot of work to be done. But posting stuff like this a week before the election feels sort of like defeatism, or anxiety manifesting across the internet.

    Is losing the preferred option? Because that’s what this sounds like. They only want to win if the motives, candidates, and vibes are perfect?

    1
    1. Haven’t clicked the links, but are they even real people? Couldn’t they be GOP/Russian/Chinese/Iranian/… Ops?

      1. Real people. The first as I noted is one of the co-founders of Run For Something, an organization that has been instrumental in recruiting people for races. The article on LitHub is by Jennifer Welch, who is an interior designer and reality show figure who started “I’ve Had It,” a fairly popular podcast.

        Now, the people amplifying this stuff? Probably a mix of foreign ops and aggrieved Americans.

        I just don’t understand the mindset. At all.

        1
        1. Reminds me a bit of the Independent Labour Party (ILP) in the UK, in the 1930’s, who kept carping at Labour for not being pure of mind and intent, and ended up being opposed to to WW2 and marginalised.

          See also Bennites, Militant, Corbynites/Momentum.
          And currently, the Greens, where a lot of Corbynites seem to have migrated, and are busily wrecking the Greens electoral prospects.
          I suspect rather to the amusement of Burnham and the rest of the Labour leadership.
          (It would be to mine, except I regret the likely loss of the Greens as an actually effective environmentalist force in some constituencies)

    2. “Let’s keep losing, so when we finally do win we do the things I want done.”
      aka letting ( a personal view of) the best be the enemy of the good.
      Litman describing Biden as having a policy of “austerity” is rather absurd.

      1
  7. In Alaska citizens receive an annual dividend from oil and mineral royalties.
    Fatso recently said;

    “I can just see the fake headlines. President Trump is talking about all the money they’re making while people are suffering at the pump. I don’t give a damn. We’re making a freaking fortune.”

    Where is my dividend check, bitch?!?

  8. Flavio Bolsonaro has fled to the U.S. to avoid money laundering charges after losing the Brazilian election and having his passport confiscated by his opponent Lula.

    1
    1. I wonder if he has sufficient money stashed to enable the Trumpkins to wet their beaks?

      It’s ironic that US influence may have tipped the right nomination to Flavio, but that and being Jair’s heir probably tipped the election against him.

      I know at least one (rather well off) Brazilian who was (last time we spoke, which was about a year ago) dubious about Lula, but inclined to consider the Bolsonaro family a bunch of lawless and constitutionally reckless crooks, and that the US should mind it’s own damn business.

    2. Typical would-be dictator fleeing to a third world country when his schemes come crashing down.

      1
      1. Lula’s comment on this probably translates best as:
        “He who has no guilt, has no fear. …
        he could have stayed here and proven that the accusations against him are untrue”.

        Lula has many faults, but he has not used the courts to pursue all political opponents, else Flavio would have been in jail, or at least disqualified from standing, long since.

        1
  9. The Dept. of MAGA Justice failed to get an indictment of Cassidy Hutchinson.
    Soooo much winning…

    2
  10. Reply to Dazed and Confused
    The Provisional Government decision to keep fighting was a massive mistake.
    But, otoh, the Germans were demanding a capitulation Kerensky etc considered intolerable, and hoped Russian patriotism absent the Tsar would get them support.
    However, the Russian working and peasant base had just given up, and the army was collapsing, and its supply from industry had also broken down, because the industrial base and transport systems were crippled by strikes.
    It just could not fight effectively.

    The peasants and returning (deserting) soldiers in the countryside were determined to seize the day and finally overturn the remnants of the gentry dominion by destroying records, seizing private estates, etc. This was generally rather independent of whatever the Bolsheviks did or did not advocate; the peasants when political at all were generally adherents of the Social Revolutionaries, who the Bolsheviks ended up “terminating with extreme prejudice”

    The returning soldiers in cities were more often co-opted by the Bolsheviks, as the Mensheviks lacked the command structure to do so.

    Lenin’s government than had the problem of negotiating with the Germans, who had little gratitude for their assistance in ending the war in the East, and when the Soviets tried to fight, the Germans stomped them.

    The Bolsheviks ended up being fortunate that the Western Allies in their turn broke the back of the Reichswehr in 1918.

    As ever, AI is plausible, but often depends on a scraped internet consensus that can be open to argument. Because what is popular on the net is not always 100% reliable.

    I recall the tale of a student at our place who relied on AI that confirmed his opinion that the US was supplying oil to Germany in 1941 was accurate, and when the references were traced back, relied on Reddit conspiraloonery, and one author convinced Errol Flynn was a Nazi agent, and another claiming Wall Street Jews had financed the Soviet Union. And said AI case rather ignored a minor problem with the proposition known as the Royal Navy. 😉

    In short, AI can be GIGO, unless its basis is broad enough, and founded on verifiable rule-sets, as in coding.

    This topic is one I happen to be familiar with, having studied under a specialist in Russian history (ave, Ronnie!), and considering the pattern of peasant land seizures and voting etc in 1917/18.