OTB image generated with Google Gemini

Final Senate Forecasts

What the polls are saying on election eve.

7

Comments

NYT (“Democrats Show Strength in Final Days of Race for the Senate, New Polls Find“):

Democrats are ahead of Republicans in almost all of the seven battleground states that will determine which party controls the Senate, according to the final set of polls from The New York Times and Siena University before the midterm elections.

The surveys found that Democrats hold sizable leads in Texas, which has not elected a Democrat to the Senate since 1988, and Kansas, which has not elected one since 1932.

To win a Senate majority, Democrats need to defend all the seats they currently hold and flip at least four seats that are currently held by Republicans. It has been seen as an uphill battle because many of the seats they need to win are in Republican strongholds.

But the new polls found Democratic candidates ahead in five states that now have Republican senators and effectively tied in a sixth. They hold leads in Kansas, Maine, Ohio and Texas and a narrow edge in Alaska. They are effectively tied in Iowa.

In Michigan, the lone top Senate battleground already held by Democrats, the poll found the Democratic candidate leading by double digits. (It was conducted before a Democratic feud erupted in Michigan this weekend.) The surveys did not include North Carolina, where polls have long found the Democrat leading and Republicans have pared back their campaign spending.

If this holds, it would be a stark contrast to the last presidential cycle, when President Trump won all seven swing states. But, of course, Maine, Ohio, Kansas, Alaska, and Iowa are all within the margin of sampling error.

Despite a known Republican lean, the RealClearPolitics polling aggregate projects a four-seat Democratic pickup, and thus a 51-49 Democratic majority, in the Senate:

Aside from slightly favoring Hinson in Iowa, the outcome is identical to the NYT/Sienna poll.

Nate Silver is charging for his detailed breakdown, but he’s projecting a 53-47 Democratic Senate with an 80.1% likelihood of Democratic Senate control.

Despite the late-breaking kerfuffles in Alaska and Michigan, I do think this will be a wave election that will flip the Senate. Democrats are simply more energized, both against President Trump and in favor of many of their own candidates.

7 responses to “Final Senate Forecasts”

  1. Let’s hope for at least 52 Dems in the senate, that would effectively neuter a Fetterman hostage holding threat.

    4
  2. Nate Silver is charging for his detailed breakdown, but he’s projecting a 53-47 Democratic Senate with an 80.1% likelihood of Democratic Senate control.

    Polymarket Democratic control of Senate is at 73%. Totally different methodologies, similar results.

    Interesting how betting markets react to both the Michigan and Alaska messes. Initially, probability of winning for El-Sayed and Peltola dips and then meander back up. Does that match reality? We’ll see.

  3. Michael Reynolds Avatar
    Michael Reynolds

    The most recent NYT polls look good. I’m going to indulge in optimism. (Gasp!) I think we keep all the Blue Senate seats, and flip Maine, Ohio, North Carolina, Texas, Kansas and Alaska, with one barely-scraped-by win: Iowa, South Carolina, Nebraska or Mississippi. My final number is 54.

    In what bizarro world is that the line-up of possible flips? Texas? Kansas? Even a real shot at South Carolina? If we get to 54 or better we’ll keep the Senate through 2028. Looking at the ’28 map, where can the Republicans even have a hope? California? Illinois? Maryland? They could look to Arizona, maybe, or a cranky Oregon. But after another two years of Trump I suspect we’ll be adding Democratic seats. (Shhh, don’t say Florida. You might jinx it.)

    1
    1. “Looking at the ’28 map, where can the Republicans even have a hope?”

      Pennsylvania (assuming Fetterman hasn’t flipped already).

      1
  4. From the image, I see that that House Coingress is a tossup, with House at 49.2% and Houss at 50.1% — I’m more optimistic than that. Trom at 23% seems accurate though.

    1. @Gustopher It’s an AI-generated image. The only question with the House is how big the Dem blowout.

  5. On Saturday night I came up with this map for my Senate predictions. Basically: Dems win in Alaska, Georgia, Maine, Michigan, Minnesota, New Hampshire, North Carolina, Ohio, and Texas, but come up short in Iowa, Kansas, and all the other red states people have been having their eye on lately. This comes out to a total of 52 seats for Dems. I based my predictions on a mix of polling, vibes, and each state’s historic lean.

    Of course, two years ago I wrote the following:

    I’m going to go out on a limb and predict that she’ll sweep all seven battleground states for a total of 319 EVs.

    So you are free to take anything I say with a grain of salt.