5 responses to “MORNING TROLL ALERT”

1. 

   Romulus

   July 23, 2003 at 5:01 pm

   Hey James,

   Shouldn’t the appropriate word to use before another word beginning with a vowel be ‘an’ instead of ‘a’? I’m referring to this:

   “You may post without including your e-mail address and/or a URL if you desire. If you include a URL, it will be linked to your name–your e-mail address won’t show on the page”.

   Based on the grammar lesson you gave me regarding the use of ‘its’ and ‘it’s’ you probably have it right. But………it sure sounds funny to say ‘a url’ to my ungramatically correct ear. Have a nice day. 🙂
2. 

   James Joyner

   July 23, 2003 at 5:17 pm

   Romulus,

   No. It’s confusing when you read it but not when you speak it. The rule is:

   “A” Versus “An”
   This last topic is undoubtedly the easiest, because most non-native speakers already know about the difference between a and an. They are simply two variations of the indefinite article. A is used before words that begin with consonant sounds (a rock, a large park) and an is used before vowel sounds (an interesting subject, an apple).

   However, note that the choice of a or an depends on pronunciation, not spelling. Many words that begin with the vowel -u- are preceded by a instead of an because the -u- spelling is often pronounce -yu-, as in useful (“a useful idea”), and uranium (“a uranium isotope”). In addition, in a few words borrowed from French, the initial consonant -h- is not pronounced: an heir to the throne, an hour-long lecture, an honorable agreement, etc.

   Source: RPI Writing Center
3. 

   Romulus

   July 23, 2003 at 9:31 pm

   James,
   Thanks once again for the grammar lesson.
   I figured you were right but thought that ‘a url’
   sounded strange and didn’t seem to go well together.
4. 

   Ray

   October 2, 2003 at 9:40 am

   It IS “an URL” if you are saying it as if URL is “earl.” It is “a U.R.L.” if you are pronouncing the individual letters of the acronymn.